Has it occurred to anyone that Madeleine could?

Question

have been snatched by someone truly wanting a child to care for and love? I dont agree with the way they done it, but if the McCanns left those poor babies every night, crying, which now seems to be the case, maybe someone in desperation snatched as they couldnt bear to see what was happening.The family did admit that they thought they were being watched. A crying child, to someone in the frame of mind of someone so desperately wanting a baby, and couldnt have their own, could trigger a lot of emotion and unrational behaviour.

Answer 1

If the father had just looked in on the kids then they evidently werent crying.

Remember you are seeing a news story today taken completely out of context from a statement made by Mrs McCann last year. No where does it say her kids were CONSTANTLY in tears every single moment of every night.

Jumping to conclusions doesnt exactly help this case. Unless you are in the police, I'd suggest you just wait to see what happens rather than guessing what went on / is going on.

Answer 2

It is a possibility. But surely someone would have reported seeing her by now and why only take Madeline, there were 2 younger children in the room too.

Answer 3

Accoring to Tanners eye witness account the child was asleep in the arms of the abductor Mr. R .Murat.

Now if a little girl can be woken and start crying so hard for its mother that it remeberss in the morning and asks about it..

how come being carried around the streets at night in the arms a strange man did not disturb her?

Answer 4

No surely taking the younger children who would adjust easier would of happened.  As much as I would like to think that she is being well cared for I just don't think it's realistic.  But I think you have a good point about the parents leaving the children. If they wanted to go out alone in the evenings then they should gone somewhere with a babysitting service. I'm lucky as my partner and I have a week away on our once a year when my daughter goes camping with a family friend BUT when we take the family holiday it is a family holiday and we spend the time with my daughter. She is eleven  (and sensible and responsible) but I wouldn't leave her alone in a strange country to go out for the evening. When at home I will pop to the shop but never when she was the age of the McCanns children

Answer 5

yep, true, some people don't deserve children, especially when they treat them like that!

there are those of us out there who are not as fortunate!

so, to all of you who are lucky enough to have children, please look after them and bring them up correctly, as if/when you mistreat them, you are abusing your good fortune and breaking the hearts of those less fortunate

(bring on the thumbs down!)

Answer 6

Actually, that was my hope at the beginning and I said as much. Because this would have meant that Madeleine was at least safe and not at the hands of a paedo ring which STILL doesn't bear thinking about!  And if YOU thought your family was being watched, would you leave your children alone in an unlocked apartment while you went on the razz with your mates? Not me! Those two did - makes you wonder cos it wasn't exactly an intelligent move, was it?

Answer 7

i think the poor little mite is dead i think when she got snatched the peorson who snatched her paniced someone would have see her if she was still alive the 3 year old would have needed doctor's treatment at some point and this case has been told world wide so someone would have seen her i hope i am wrong but its been almost a year now

Answer 8

This is a clear cut case of bought to order abduction...if the family thought they were being watched WHY leave the children alone...wouldnt you be more on your guard??

Answer 9

No abduction...this is the red herring the McCanns introduced to avert attention from themselves....sorry to say but I think Maddie died that first day..

Answer 10

That is not possible because it has been proved that there was no blue moon in the sky that night.

Answer 11

I suppose anything is possible but if she was abducted I think it more likely that it was by someone who had been planning to take a child and saw the opportunity rather than a spur of the moment thing because they saw Maddie in distress.I strongly believe that she was originally abducted but what happened to her after that I wish I knew.

Answer 12

if that's the case they would have taken the twins as well

Answer 13

There is no proof of an abduction we only have the mccanns word that there was an abduction

Also as someone else pointed out the other children would have been taken.

If it was someone who wanted to care for the children the twins would have been ideal as they are young and would not remember their parents etc so it would be easier to bring these children up as their own as they have no memory whereas Maddie will owing to her age and speech

Answer 14

i suppose that could be the case, but wouldn't Madeline have been seen by now?? or maybe the person who stole her has kept her well hidden...

Answer 15

It is possible . . . I hope that is what happened.