Help Me <span title="Please!!!!!??????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!">Please!!!!!??????!!!!!!!!...</span>

Question

Should I add Carnell Williams or Rashard Mendenhall to my fantasy team?

Answer 1

I heard only good things about Mendenhall and many expect that he is going to take away a lot of reps from Willie. The caddy stalled before he got hurt and he is not #1 anymore. I rather take a chance on Mendenhall, I think he also has a good size and should get goal line situations.

Answer 2

cadillac for sure. mendenhall is good but wont get nearly as many touches as cadillac. he played in 4 games last year and had 3 TDs. ill take that. mendenhall has no experience and is behind willie parker.

Answer 3

i would take mendenhall... carnell williams isn&#039;t going to get much reps... because earnest graham came in and showed what he could do and carnell is coming off an injury... and i think rashard mendenhall will get more reps and i eventually bye mid season or so mendenhall will take over the running back spot over willie..

Answer 4

Williams all the way baby

Answer 5

Cadallic is a suitable name for Williams b/c even in his first year off the &quot;college lot&quot; and into the NFL, he has been breaking down (just like a real Cadallic).  Mendenhall is the add here.  Tampa got signed Graham to an extension, so unless he gets hurt, Cadallic won&#039;t be starting anyway.  Plus, Cadallic has to compete with 3 RBs for carries (Graham, Dunn, + Bennett), whereas Mendenhall is the undisputed backup on a team that does RB by committee work historically.  Plus, look what Davenport was able to do as Parker&#039;s backup last year (more than 6 rushing TDs).  Add the fact that Parker is coming off a season where he broke his leg also.  MENDENHALL!!!  You&#039;ll thank me later.

Answer 6

i like williams because mendenhall wont get many chances because he is a rookie and because he has parker in front of him

peace...