Help with Baseball trade?????

Question

I was offered:

Manny

BJ Upton

For:

Chase Utley

Ian Stewart

I think I may counter to include Furcal...so I would get manny, upton, and furcal.

Or they offered manny and dice-k for utley.

This is a 15 player keeper league. We keep 15 from year to year...any thoughts????

Answer 1

do it

Answer 2

Manny is on fire know and Utley isnt dont trade Manny know for that only u can probably get Holliday or even Hamilton dont trade him know w8 abit u can get lots of good players for him

Answer 3

good trade say yes or do Utley for Braun strait up

Answer 4

No dont take the trade especially since it is a keeper league.Ian Stewart is the most highly tauted prospect to ever come out of Colorado.He is a hitter in a hitters park.BJ has a great upside but Ian Stewart is going to be huge.Utley is still young and has 10 more years of playing than Manny which is a huge consideration in a keeper league.I would keep both of your future MVPs.

Answer 5

You are getting two OF and giving up 2 IF players. Player scarcity is important here. Utley is the top 2nd baseman. Furcal is on the 60 day DL and won't be back until late August early September.

Don't do that deal or the other one. Trust me.

Answer 6

Manny and Dice K for Utley lets run with that one!!!

Answer 7

Do it manny is better than Utley and Upton is def better than Stewart