Help with an NFL Fantasy Trade?

Question

Payton Manning, Vernon Davis, DJ Hackett for Marc Bulger, Andre Johnson, and Kellen Winslow

I have Payton Vernon and DJ

Should i accept this trade?

Answer 1

no way, keep Peyton manning

Answer 2

no because the Qb is a huge difference    davis could turn  out close to winslow and johnson is better than hackett but peyton is so much better than bulger

Answer 3

Really depends on your team Bulger is coming off an injury and a QB like Manning is irreplacable. Who is your back up QB? And do you have a need at TE and WR. If I were you I would probably do it, you get a #1 WR, a #1 TE and a #2 QB for a top tier #1 QB a #2 TE and a who knows what he is going to do WR. If you think about it like that then you should make the deal.

Answer 4

Ok, first of all, Andre Johnson is a super stud, missed like 8 weeks last season ans still put better numbers than receivers like Roy Williams, Santonio Holmes, etc. BUT, the big BUT is that he missed 8 weeks last season and was bothered with a groin injury.

Winslow is another stud, but a little banged up.

If you knew these two guys were gonna give you a full season, then the trade is a Yes..

Answer 5

NO.  Manning had surgery but do you really think he will lose his 160 game streak?  He's Peyton Manning and he has amazing receivers around him.  Do not trade away Manning!

Answer 6

h**l no

I would never give up Manning to get Bulger back