How do i punish my puppy, she is so....?!?!?!?

Question

my puppy is just a load of trouble today she got into her treat box and ate everything, i was really angry cause she was starving herself from eating her normal food and gave up and was starting to eat, UNtiL the treat box tradgedy. i forgot to tke it out of her reach so yeah yeah blah blah its my fault. now she is STUFFED with treats and won't eat her normal food even more!!!! i was so mad i hit her a lot when i caught her (never touched those box of treats again). i know hitting is wrong, but tapping and nooo's! don't work for her! once she ate some bark and when i tried to take it out of her muth she clamped her jaws shut, ran away and swallowed (another problem). i caught her (didn't call) as soon as i cuold and tapped her nose and said no firmly. she didn't even notice the tap and ignored my no and walked away. i tried the "proper dicipline" and it DIDNT WORK. she still eats bark and ignores da tapping and no's. i also tried the crate trick but it had the same lame result (can't even take crates on walks)and what is so wrong about hitting?!. is there a better WORKING way to disipline my pup? or is hitting the only way?

Answer 1

shes a puppy she doesnt know better. i cant balieve your actually hitting a LIVING, BREATHING CREATURE!! get a dog trainer!!!!

X-P

GRRRRR

Answer 2

i have an 8 month old Chihuahua and she used to do the same thing so I started putting her on a leash outsideand leaving her there with water for 30 minutes although I live in the country so try locking her in a room maybe the bathroom, put some water in there make sure you put everything up and just leave mer in there don't baby her act as if she's not there. Trust me it's hard because I love my dog and it killed me but after she realized that if she got into things then she would have to be by herself for a while she stop but it took about 2 months for mine to learn so good luck.

Answer 3

Please take your dog to a no kill shelter so they can find it a GOOD home. You obviously are not equipped to handle a pet. Then do not get another. Some people should not have pets. They shouldn't have children, either.  

Answer 4

Why in the world do you need to discipline the dog to begin with? Why is it her fault that YOU have not trained her? Your dog does not know what is proper behavior and what is improper behavior until you take the time to teach and train her - and there's a huge difference between training a dog and terrifying a dog.

Get off your a*s and get a dog trainer.

Answer 5

Get a life psycho and stop abusing your dog.  People without patience should not have a puppy.  It takes time and consistancy to train a pup.  These are two things it sounds like you dont have.  It would be better to give the puppy back and try again when you have more time to devote to firm consistant training.  

Answer 6

She's a puppy for god's sake!!! That's what they do!

At first, you will be like "ugh why did I ever get this darn dog!" puppies are always nightmares when you first get them, all it takes is patience and good obedience classes, then you will wonder how you ever lived without her

*and don't hit your poor puppy! That's abuse :(

Answer 7

I'm sorry, but you are focusing on discipline and quick results rather than training over the long term.

I would suggest that you sign up for a hands-on training class by a professional dog trainer.  Petco and Petsmart both offer low cost group classes.

One final note:  If I ever saw you, or anyone else, actually hitting their dog?  I'd call 9-1-1 and have the cops on you so fast it would make your head spin.  So don't EVER hit your dog again; that's abuse and it's not only wrong, it's criminal.  If that's going to be a problem for you, it's time to find your dog a new home.

Answer 8

If you know it was your fault that you left the treats within reach why would you "hit her a lot"? And "the crate trick" is not for punishment nor is it a trick, if used properly it's a method to house train a pup. You need to get your pup to obedience training and learn correct techniques to correct bad behavior. Pups are trained with patience, firmness and kindness, yelling and hitting doesn't work. If obedience training isn't an option check out books from the library or go on line and do some reading about methods to correct your pup, you won't find any trainer that recommends hitting.  

Answer 9

Punishing a dog is always wrong..it does not teach them anything other then to fear you. Dogs don't understand that they have done something wrong. and if they do they forgive themselves before you notice what they have done and they are then confused as to why they are "in trouble"

Tapping a dog on the nose is not an effective why of training nor is just saying no.

I'm going to leave you with two different sites, please take the time to read some of the articles..they will help you better understand the concept of training a dog.

You don't discipline a dog you train them.

http://www.aspca.org/site/PageServer?pag...

http://veterinarypartner.com/Content.plx...

Answer 10

Smashing is only half right - dogs won't starve themselves but changing its food every month will only make the problem worse.  Don't feed her, and she will eat eventually.

As far as hitting goes - is it getting the results you want?  You may want to try a training class - they generally work.

Answer 11

I agree with Lucey Cares. Why are you hitting her? Poor dog.

Answer 12

It sounds stupid but dogs really react to your face and tone of voice.

look at the dog with a very serious face...just to show your not playing,

and very strongly but not to loud say no. Also you might want to try making a low grunting noise, thats what a dogs mother would do to show the dog she disaproved.

Answer 13

There are appropriate methods available to train your puppy in almost every area that may need some help and none of them suggest inflicting pain on your pet. They are not people and DO NOT correlate the association of the "wrong" action with a harsh punishment. All that you will accomplish with hitting your dog is teaching her to distrust and fear you, leaving your problems unsolved and that much more difficult to resolve down the road with a fearful and wary puppy.

You have to decide what it is that you would like to work on or have her do. The food issue is something that requires time and patience. Dogs and puppies will eat when they are hungry. They can be finicky, but will eventually eat. Put her food down for about 10 minutes, if she does not eat take her food away, but offer the food at least three-four times a day, depending on her age, and at consistent times. You can try adding a bit of water to entice her, but make certain she is not getting snacks in between her meals, of any kind. If she continues to hold out on her food for more than two days or begins to exhibit other symptoms of illness, like vomiting, lethargy, or diarrhea, take her to the vet immediately. Always make sure she has access to clean water at all times.

If your othe rcomplaint is that she picks things up in her mouth and won't let go, she would benefit from the "drop it" command. This command is as common as sit, stay, and come, all of which should be taught early on to prevent negative behavior later on. I would recommend getting a basic obedience and training your puppy book from your local pet store, they are reasonable in price, yet will supply endless benefits for you and your dog.

Please don't hit your dog, it is certainly the fastest way to create more problems and fix none.  

Answer 14

You need to educate yourself on how to deal with dogs.  Physical discipline, even tapping, will only damage the relationship you have with your dog.  

You need to find a dog food she likes, and then stick with that brand.  

You are responsible for where you leave her treats.  If you leave them where she can get into them, and you feel the urge to hit something, hit yourself.  

There should be no problem with your dog eating bark, it is a natural substance.  I would say she is teething, and needs more things she can chew on that you provide.  Get yourself to the pet store, and get a nylon bone, and some dried pigs ears.  

Crate training is meant to enforce toilet training, not to be a punishment.  The crate should be her den, her safe place.

Get the two of you into obedience class, it will do the world of good for both of you.  

Answer 15

You puppy didn't do anything wrong...you did. She should not of been punished for eating something she likes and that you left in her reach. All puppies chew bark, wood, and anything else they can get in their mouth. Your lack of information and / or training makes your expectations too high for a puppy. Learn more about how to care for your puppy and what her breed requires. If you know what to expect, you won't expect so much and become so angry. For everyday problems like chewing on your toes and furniture, try a spray bottle with water in it. It doesn't hurt but she will not like it. Stop hitting your dog.