How do u rate Dhoni and Gilly(Gilchrist)?

Question

How do u rate Dhoni and Gilly(Gilchrist)?

Answer 1

Both very good keeper/batsman.

Gilchrist is probably the best ever , so you cant make a comparison between the two.

Answer 2

gilchrist is a world class player.......

one thing i admire ab8 him is his honesty.....

he walks out of the field if he knows he is out, not waiting for the umpires decision..........which is very rare, him being an australian!!!!!

dhoni has a long way to go, although he is a very gifted player/....

Answer 3

I don't think you can compare them to be honest.

While Dhoni is a good keeper Gilly was one of the greatest and has a much greater standing in the history of the game. He revolutionized the way wicketkeepers were thought of and used. Because of his influential standing within the game and the improvisation he showed with the bat wicketkeepers are now required to show more than a little initiative with their batting. He made specialist wicketkeepers who could only catch the ball pretty much obsolete.

Answer 4

gilly is opener  and  dhoni is middle order player .

as far as records are concerned , dhoni is ahead of gilly as he hits 183 runs in an innings which is highest by wicket keeper batsman ,

but both are equally spectecular with different techniques.

dhoni like gilchrist also walks when he knicks one.

Answer 5

Gilchrist is a good cricketer and ahis shots are elegant.

But dhoni is a clean hitter of the ball and not so elegant strokes. But Gilchrist was never a player to do a responsible role. But nowadays Dhoni has matured a lot and doning the Captain role with elegance and cleverness. He does the man management well.

Answer 6

You cant compare the 2,Dhoni is an ok keeper,but has the weight of the world on his shoulders..

Where as Adam Gilchrist was THE best wicket keeper and Vice captain inthe world..He was also a better batsman I.M.O.P...

Answer 7

Both are fantastic cricketers in their own rights...

Gilchrist is a prolific attacking batsman and superb behind the wickets..... He has revolutionize the game and made it stylish....also a very good human-being

Dhoni on the other hand is also the fastest rising star in Indian and World Cricket... But much has to be seen coz he is still very early days him as a captain.... The stuff that makes him stand out in the crowd is his nerves.... he has Nerves of Steel...nah...Titanium I suppose....

Answer 8

dhoni will become a amazing cricket after his innings yesterday. gilchrist was a legend he could keep good and was a talented batsmen how fought his way to his runs

Answer 9

Equal

Answer 10

Any player can be compared to any other player.

ODI Cricket (Relative Performance on a 0-1,000 scale - Batting/Bowling/Fielding/Overall). Both are on par though Dhoni is slightly lesser than Gilchrist in batting and fielding, his overall contribution is at the same level.

Gilchrist - 752/0/989/782

Dhoni - 726/0/919/782

Test Match Cricket (Relative Performance on a 0-1,000 scale - Batting/Bowling/Fielding/Overall). Gilchrist is superior to Dhoni. Dhoni has not done justice to his talent in test match cricket which is all about patience, perseverence, phasing and performance.

Gilchrist - 432/0/935/543

Dhoni - 346/0/644/417

Answer 11

Gilchrist is a class as a batsman as a keeper. Dhoni is nothing. He is the worst, captain , keeper what not !

Answer 12

We should not compare.

Gilly has had years of experience and excellence.

Dhoni is good and rising. He is a good wicket keeper. But his crown is very heavy. Give him time and space.

Answer 13

I like MAHENDRA SINGH DHONI more ,because he is a good keeper & a good player & a good captain also.

Answer 14

No Match . Both are completely different.

Its same like we always used to think between boucher & gilchrist.

Gilchrist can play any form of the game.

But Dhoni has yet to prove himself in the Tests. He has only 1 century in his bag which he scored against pakistan in pakistan.

Answer 15

Dhoni is not, & will never be in Gilchrist's league.

Answer 16

dhoni;-he is a thinking crickter.

gylly-he is a pinch hitter.

Answer 17

there should never be compared to each other. yes Dhoni has done well in one dayers and has a high average of 47, but 1/3 of his innings have ended in not out, which is why he has such a high average. plus Gilchrist opens and has a better strike rate than dhoni.

However test matches are the real deal, and Gilchrist has done really well, he averages 48, while dhoni has a pathetic average of 32.

Answer 18

if Gilly is 10 then dhoni is on 5