How do you compare teams in the NL East separately on all levels?

Question

I suggest justifying your answer, because I know the clear cut facts, so I'll be choosing who is most correct and/or justified. No biased answers from any team, please.

Offense

Defense

Rotation

Bullpen

Infield

Outfield

Closer

Manager

You can just do contenders if you'd like.

Answer 1

Well i would like to just say phillies phillies phillies cuz thats my team but i will be honest.....

Offense- i would say the phillies because of the big 4 utley, howard, burrell and j-rolls....plus they have 3 of the 4 with at least 30 homeruns(only the 3rd time in history)

Defense- im going to say phillies also because of gold glover pedro feliz at third and ryan howard is a great defensive firstbasemen.....then u got victorino in center who can cover alot of ground and burrell in left with a cannon of an arm.....not to mention j-rolls and utley up the middle

Rotation- im going with the mets....they have a good rotation with starting with santana. then they have john maine who has had sum injury problems and also oliver perez who is really good when hes on. but its there bullpen that kills them....

Bullpen- im goin to go with the phillies.....they have one of the best bullpens in the national league especially lidge who has 31 saves.

Infield- phillies offensively and probably defensively too.....howard, utley, rollins, and feliz

Outfield- im not sure....maybe the mets because they have beltran who is a gold glover and endy chavez and fernando tatis has done a good job filling in for all the injuries to moises alou and ryan church...

but when all of them are healthy i think they have the best.

Closer- no question Brad lights out Lidge......like i said 31 saves....kevin greg of the marlins isnt to bad either.

Manager- im going to say Charlie Manuel of the phillies...although jerry manuel has definitley improved the mets since being named manager...

Hopefully that wasnt tooo much...haha

Answer 2

Offense-Phillies

Defense-?

Rotation-Mets

Bullpen-Def NOT METS haha.

Infield- Either mets or Phillies

Outfield-Mets

Closer-Philles, since Wagner is out and has Lidge blown a save yet?

Manager-Philies

Answer 3

Offense - Phillies

Defense - Phillies

Rotation - Mets

Bullpen - Phillies!!

Infield - Phillies

Outfield - Phillies

Closer - Phillies, Lidge is perfect in save opp.

Manager - I think good 'Ol Charlie