How do you justify an Indian muslim's love for Pakistan,Even when his nation is facing crisis?

Question

Lets leave politics aside,I am asking this bcoz many muslims in India,talk for pakistan,no matter how badly their own nation is in trouble.

I dn't mind them loving another nation.But the direct implication of this "love" is that muslim minority around all over India is tortured in that name and people ignore all oppression against muslims by saying "Oh,never mind,these muslims deserve this bcoz they are loyal to pakistan even when they opt to stay in India".

What is your comment on this??

Salm\am and thanks..

Answer 1

This ummah is one.

We love each other because we are muslims.

Answer 2

That's not cool, deporting Indians to Pakistan, for what reason? they have every right to stay in their home country.

I think Muslims, ALL Muslims, should put their religion BEFORE their nationality and not worry if they have love for another Muslim country. Actually, I think the Muslims should ingnore what country another Muslim is from and just love/respect/help their fellow Muslims. Islam does not recognize race and nationality. But too bad so many Muslims forget that. I know it is difficult for Muslims living in non-Muslim countries (some much worse than others), this is Allah's test for us, we must try to get thru it.

Answer 3

i don't think so any indian muslim at least in 2008 can favor pakistan as in coming few more years pakistan will be divided into 4 or more pieces. so how can they favor such a country? their own country India is now economically Strong how can they love or favor a sinking boat?

Answer 4

If Indian Muslims love Pakistan so much, and if that is where there loyalty lies if theres another war, they should be deported to Pakistan their beloved country.

Answer 5

Indian Muslims Love Pakistani Muslims

Pakistani Muslims Love Indian Muslims

In Which world do u live in???

Answer 6

You sound like a bigot out to create fiction between an average muslim- hindu in India that doesn't exist.

Hindu and Muslims are very well adjusted with each other in India in a normal life basis. They share schools, colleges, best of goverment jobs, Presidents position etc.

If you refer to the recent bombing of the so called Indian mujahudeen's they are nothing but a few extremist that you find just any where in this world. How can India be spared considering a 25 percent of our population is Muslim. But that does not mean an average muslim in India's loyalty lies in pakistan or his muslim brothers in Iran or some other country.

My Muslim friends in India think like the rest of the Hindus, Pakistan is a looser country  

Answer 7

I'd say that it is v. natural and perfect for a Muslim to love his brothers and sisters. Why, that is what Islam tells us!

As far as the jealousy of the narrow minded Hindus is concerned, it's very normal. That's exactly what Allah tells us in the Quran. They can never wish us well. Of course, Muslim unity is gonna strike them abhorrent. What should be done? Should the Indian Muslims stop loving all other Muslims? Can u guarantee that it is the only cause of the Hindus' hatred? And if this is eliminated, their hatred will cease? Did the Hindus never oppress the Muslims before the formation of Pakistan?

Don't worry about them, sis.! They're gonna find one excuse, or another.

I can just agree with Waqas----thanks God my grandparents left the country of those narrow minded people at the time of partition!

Answer 8

We talk for Pakistan for the same reason you mentioned - because most pakistanis are muslims, and muslims in India are very often discriminated against.