How is Indian going to benefit from the new nuclear agreement with US ? What are the pros and cons of it ?

Question

What is ur personal opinion on this ? Do u support this treaty or disagree with it

Answer 1

lets just say WW III is around the corner

Answer 2

They are going to blow the S**t out of Pakistan!!

Answer 3

I completely agree to Geeta

I think most of the common people of India don't know the exact pros and cons of this deal...

Have a great day friend :-)

Answer 4

B. Queen !Are you doing survey for any political party?

-Sudan

Answer 5

this deal will help India to find a permanent place on the nuclear map of the world. It gives India access to the world's nuclear fuel resources and the permission to develop nuclear fuels for research and for civil purposes.

But i think one thing that who the h**l gave the US right to say whether we are allowed to make nuclear weapons or not. Its our choice how, when, where we want to use our resources and we will do that.

Answer 6

In fact Govt of India has failed to bring to the notice of the common public various benefits of Nuke Deal.  Only political angle is known to all.  From the beginning, Govt. should have reach to the masses and impress upon them the need to have Nuke agreement.  In the longer run, there will be huge gap between demand and supply of power and Nuke deal will be able to fill that great vaccume.

Answer 7

When two govts are supporting it must begood for development of both countries. Indian scientific & technical expertise will become comparable to the same of USA. India will progress tremendously, I speculate. India has not have sufficient Uranium reserves. So, she needs Uranium to be purchased from some other country. USA is the best one so far.

Answer 8

Very smart, beauty and brains, brilliant question!

Answer 9

The US and the 45 countries (NSG-Nucleasr Supplier Group) have a monopoly over the enriched. They have been withholding such materials to nations who have not signed the NPT(Non-Proliferation Treaty). For a numbers of years, India, which had consistenly refused to sign the NPT, suffered without adquate supply of the enriched uranium and other technologies. Now, President Bush, in recognition of the growing importance of India for its strategic consideration came forward to give a waiver from the NPT requirement in the case of India and the result was the 123 Agreement. The Left is objecting to this agreement mainly because this makes India a close partner to US in their capitlistic global designs and the BJP, although is not fundamentally averse to a special relations with the US, finds fault with the Hydes Act. According to the latter Act, any international agreement which runs counter to the objective of non-pliferation of nuclear technology, will be such restrictions and conditions imposed by the Senate. But, the US says that there is no problem with the latter Act. The Congress led coalition governemnt says that in view of the growing energy needs of India, we need to have a re-look at the entire issue and that we need to have nuclear energy at any cost. It says that enough safeguards have been taken to maitain our soverign right to defend ourselves either with our nuclear weapons or without it and that the 123 Agreement shall not come in the way of that right. Now, the Left parties have withdrawn their support to the government and it is to be seen wheterh Congress is able to cobble up enough support to remain in the governemtn so that further steps like go to IAEA and sendig the Agreement for the ratification by the Senate before Bush's tenure comes to an end.