How is this for a trade?

Question

I give up David Wright, Brian Fuentes and Derek Lowe for A.J.Burnett, Carlos Lee and Jose Valverde.

My other 3B is Ryan Zimmerman so basically I wont have a 3B till he is back. My OF are Cuddyer, Beltran, Hawpe and Murphy (texas)....what do you guys think of the trade...is it fair? am I giving too much?

Answer 1

You got ripped off.

Answer 2

i dont think burnett is actually doing that good....

Answer 3

take david wright out and put in one of your outfielders.

Answer 4

Why the rush to make a trade?  And why give up a potential 30-30 in Wright to wait for Zimm who at best is .265, 25 on a team that scores very few runs?  Why have you kept Hawpe all this time?  And your're getting nothing from Cuddyer this year.  Lee's hitting what, .260?  If you offered me that trade I'd take it but I might not want to get rid of Valverde.

Answer 5

You're getting ripped off. Wright is top 5 talent and the highest you're getting back is top 20 (Lee). Zimmerman may be out for a while rehabbing.