How many sects do Mut'ah? Is it only shias?

Question

How many sects do Mut'ah? Is it only shias?

Answer 1

yes maybe

Answer 2

Thank God , Sunnah dont allow such stuff!

Answer 3

in fact its not in Glorious Quran,so therefore its no where,however,this thing is found in hadith books ,shia's and sunni's alike.in sunni hadith books it is stated that it was allowed and was decreed by Allah Allmighty as per their books,and later on Umer stopped this practice..i put the same question to both shias and sunnis,why did Umer stopped this practice if it was decreed by Allah Allmighty or Prophet Muhammed,why Umer defied Allah's command and how dare he did ..

Answer 4

Even among shias its usuall poors and economically need who for the sake of money do it with rich guys

Answer 5

One of the views of some Quran only Muslims  about mutah marriage is that  they consider marriage is a contract written by the consent of the 2 parties BUT they put the regulations of it according to the Quran not according to shiaa , they say if he married her for one day or even for one hour then to divorce her she has to stay  in his house for 3 months and he has to pay her money for  divorcing her as per Quran . If it turned out that she is pregnant during those 3 months then she has to stay in his house until she delivers and the child has the right for support and inheritance.

Answer 6

Mutah was very familiar in Muhammad's time and no I am not having a dig at Islam. It was. Just go look up some websites. Well it seems forbidden now. I guess Shias still practice it.  

Answer 7

i think only shia do mutah.

Answer 8

I have not come across any Shia who does it most don't agree with it.

Answer 9

Only shia do Mutah, and it is totally haram either way.

check answering-christianity for the answer.

Answer 10

Mut'ah is totally haram...usually shia guys use sunni girls for Mut'ah.

Answer 11

Mut'ah is a type of marriage, used in the same way as a permanent marriage (Nikah) in order to make a man and woman physically halaal to each other. A Mut'ah is a temporary marriage that ends at a fixed period. Imam of Ahl as-Sunnah Waheed ad-Deen az-Zaman, in his footnotes of Sunan ibn Majah, defined Mut'ah as follows:

Mut'ah is a type of Nikah until an agreed time. It can be for a day, two days, a month, one year, three years etc.

Waheed ad-Deen az-Zaman. Sunan Ibn Majah. Volume 2, p. 76

Imam Nawawi in his commentary of Sahih Muslim, relied on the definition of Mut'ah advanced by Imam of Ahle Sunnah Qadi Iyad as follows:

وَاتَّفَقَ الْعُلَمَاء عَلَى أَنَّ هَذِهِ الْمُتْعَة كَانَتْ نِكَاحًا إِلَى أَجَل لَا مِيرَاث فِيهَا , وَفِرَاقهَا يَحْصُل بِانْقِضَاءِ الْأَجَل مِنْ غَيْر طَلَاق

"Ulema agree that this Mut'ah is a Nikah in which the husband and wife do not inherit from eachother and separation would take place on the completion of the Specified time without Talaq".

Sharh Sahih Muslim, Volume 4 page 13

The Sunni scholar Allamah 'Abd Ar-Rahman al-Jazeri in his Al-fiqh 'Ala Al-Madhahib al-Arba' said:

أما حقيقة نكاح المتعة، فهو أن يقيد عقد الزواج بوقت معين، كأن يقول لها: زوجيني نفسك شهراً. أو تزوجتك مدة سنة. أو نحو ذلك، سواء كان صادراً أمام شهود وبمباشرة ولي، أولا

The reality of Nikah Mut'ah is that, in the marriage recital performed with a woman, words are added which stipulate that the marriage is for a fixed time. For example a man shall say 'she shall remain as my wife for a month, or I shall have Nikah Mut'ah with you for a year." The parties themselves act as witnesses. It can occur in the presence of a Wali or witnesses, or without them.

Al-fiqh 'Ala Al-Madhahib al-Arba' (Lahore Edition) Volume 4, page 167

The book can also be downloaded from the following Salafi library

http://saaid.net/book/open.php?cat=4&boo...