How should i get rid of, mariano rivera or jonathan papelbon?

Question

i already have francisco rodriguez so i want to get rid of one of these two but i am completely stumped on which one to trade. plz help.

Answer 1

I would trade Jonathan Papelbon and try to sure up a position that you are weak in.

Answer 2

It depends on what you need.  Check on whoever is last or second last in saves and work on them.  When  people are lacking in certain categories they tend to be more willing to deal for players that will boost that category.

Answer 3

Whatever you do, keep 1 so you have more than 1 closer.

Papelbon will get you more value than Rivera.

Answer 4

If it's a keeper league, I would hold on to Pap (Age), otherwise get good value for the one you trade.