How skinny is TOO skinny?

Question

With this question I'd like pictures of bodies;

A picture of your IDEAL girl (and/or guy), in terms of body size/type (try to make it a pic where you can clearly see most of the body).

And then judge these girls, too skinny or just fine?:

http://www.radreport.net/wp-content/uploads/2007/11/hilary_duff_fhm.jpg

http://www.phreecelebs.com/main/wp-content/uploads/2007/11/hilary-duff-fhm-uk-december-outtake.jpg

http://img.suicidegirls.com/media/albums/0/35/1350/347781.jpg

Answer 1

they all look okay to me. the last one maybe could do with an extra 3 kgs.

Answer 2

Too Skinny is when girls look like they REALLY NEED TO EAT. i mean they look like they are dying

The pictures you poseted Hillary looks fine she isnt to skinny. She is thin  but she has meat on her bones. She struggled through anorexia but she started to work out and eat. She looks better then these girls

http://www.starling-fitness.com/wp-conte...

http://cache.boston.com/bonzai-fba/Reute...

http://www.aolcdn.com/red_galleries/skin...

Answer 3

Too skinny is when the girl's height is 5'9 but only weighing 90 lbs.

http://www.trendhunter.com/images/phpthu...

Answer 4

there not that skinny, iv seen skinner

Answer 5

the first two are fine, but the last girl could use a little meat on her bones!

Answer 6

To rate those pics:

1 and 2 get about 1/10

the third one gets a 5/10

I think you can guess what type of body I like

This one's one of my favourites

http://i21.photobucket.com/albums/b284/n...

Answer 7

TOO skinny is a body size not appropriate for your height..... :)

Answer 8

they look healthy for me. i think if their BMI is 18.5 or below

then thats the time i can safely say they are skinny.