How would you rank Melo, Carter, T-Mac, Pierce?

Question

Rank them and explain why you chose that order.

Answer 1

1. Melo. Strong leader rookie.

2. Carter. Dunk skill.

3. Pierce. Strong will.

4. T-Mac. Fighter.

Answer 2

1. Melo- best inside outside game in the NBA, best low post player in the game right now, deadly from the outside and inside.

2. Carter- still one of the most versatile players in the league, all around team player and still can out jump most of the young guys in the league and capable of leading a team.

3. T-Mac- better all around game through the years and still can score in bunches and pile up the points when needed

4. Pierce- the truth?? finals MVP?? main reason: KG and ray allen, if not for those guys pierce and the celts would still be missing the playoffs. that only shows he can't lead a team by himself. but still can upgrade his stats individually.

Answer 3

1. T-mac- If it wasn't for injuries destroying his career.. He would be one of the best in the game!! He's a beast and has a GREAT JUMPSHOT!

2. Melo- He did good in the Olympic Games... Really good offensive player.

3. Pierce- He's getting old, but proved in the Finals that he still has some left in the tank...

4. Carter- One of the TOP Dunkers in NBA History.. He was a great all-around player back then.. Had his 3's.. But now they're faded.. Give the man props and respect..

Answer 4

Talent wise

1. Melo

2. Pierce

3. T-Mac

4. Carter

In order of who I like

1. T-Mac

2. Pierce

3. Carter

4. Melo

Answer 5

my favorite

1) t mac

2) carter

3) melo

4) pierce

if i had to pick 1

t-mac can and has carry a team on his back( note thats why he have back injuries) but is a better one on one player and a better defender then other three

if i had to pick one as a team player this year

melo is younger and can score almost automatic when in a grove if he improves passing and outside stroke and play harder defense then he has the potential to be a dominant player  like scottie pippen but should not have star status

Answer 6

I would put Pierce at 1 because he has always been able to play but was on a bad team and only got up for big games and this year he showed that he can play and defend with the best of them.  He went up against the two best player in the league and was able to play with Lebron James and he actually outplayed Kobe Bryant so I would rank him 1

2   would be Melo right now a little bit over Tmac because of his youth and Melo has championship experience in college but he is lacking a killer instinct if he had that killer instinct he would be up there with Bryant and James.

3    I would put Tmac at 3 and I would actually  put him 1 or 2 if he was healthy.  He has a bad back and that has slow his game down quite a bit.  But he still has game and defends pretty good but like I said he was one of the game best if not the best before his back started to bother him.

4    Carter,  He has to be a little bit of a disappointment for his fan and the NBA.  He has the or had the best athletic gift of them all and had one of the best athletic gift of anyone who ever played the game but I believe and so do a lot of other people believe he did not work on his game.  He was up there eith Kobe and a lot of people thought he was better and I was one of them but kobe worked on his game and carter did not and other people has past him.

Answer 7

by whose the best and not wat thy hav done

1.tracy mcgrady-takes over any game by himself and can b a beast in any catergory

2.melo-when he was drafted b4 he got AI he broght the team to the playoffs ever year..he has a nice shot and is to big for reglar forwards to defend

3.pierce-is a good player but not as good as melo and tmac

4.carter-he doesnt really do much cept dunk

Answer 8

Right now, Paul Pierce is #1 of this group because he won the NBA championship and was the Finals MVP...

Carmelo Anthony is #2, he has been solid all season and in the Olympics.

T-Mac is #3, only mostly because of his injuries and the fact that he can't get his team out of the first round of the play-offs.

Vince Carter is a shadow of his old self, but still a good player, he never really got that killer instinct on the court...

Answer 9

Current:

1. Pierce - Finals MVP, the best award in basketball (he had a great series)

2. T-MAC - Played with injuries or he would be #1

3. Carmelo - Great offense, but he is still in the learning process of being a great player.

4. Vince Carter: Injuries,injuries,injuries "Half man half hurt" he just isnt the same player, with out his athletic abilities.

Answer 10

Carmelo Anthony

Tracy McGrady

Paul Pierce

Wince, I mean Vince Carter

It's the same order for talent and the order for who I am a bigger fan of.

Answer 11

1. T-Mac- If it wasn't for injuries he would be the best player in the league. He can shoot, get to the basket whenever he wants, defend.

2. Pierce- Very good all-around player. His defense improved this year.

3. Melo- He would be higher if he could defend, but he's got a lot of talent.

4. Carter- He had a lot of potential, but didn't really use it. He could never really do much but dunk, but now he can't really do a lot of that because of his knees. Now the only thing he can do is take a bunch of 3's and miss most of them.