Huge Chase Utley Trade?

Question

i would be giving

miguel cabrera , Jay Bruce , and Jon Garland

i would get Chase Utley

i would be winning this because i would be selling bruce high and garland is good but nowhere near webb or santana's level

plus evan longoria woult take over for cabrera and i would also have yunel escobar to take over 2b , 3b and SSand i have backup pitchers in mcgowan and dice-k.....cause hes sort of cold and not so hot right now..........i think i should do this just for the fact that i have the guys to back up what i lose but if i dednt have the good bench then i would never do it

Yes or NO?

Answer 1

no,no, and no last i checked utley was 0 for his last 23 at bats...with cabrera and bruce theres too more chances you'll get the amount of productivity as utley even though utley will probably be N.L. MVP...and garland is a decent starter, dice-k is coming off an injury where he just gave up a career high in runs.

Answer 2

do it-  Utley is a huge upgrade over everybody else at 2nd and over most other players.

Bruce is way over valued for a rookie, Garland isnt that great

Answer 3

Do it, you have Dice K on the bench, he is ready to go again after getting hit by STL, and Mig Cab is just not hitting like the Fantasy Leading Utley. Plus Evan Almighty just hit his 12th HR of the year adding power to the Rays lineup.

Answer 4

Do it.  So what if he is 0/23.  That just means you are getting him at a discount price.

Answer 5

Yes.  I only wish someone would give up Utley in my league.

Answer 6

YES, go for it!

Answer 7

Definitely a yes. Cabrera and Bruce are struggling and as long as long your pitching isn't as bad as mine. Besides, Longoria and Escobar are great and can backup Cabrera. Longoria can hit for power and get rbi's and Escobar can score runs and hit for average. McGowan and Dice K are both better than Garland, so you can definitely get rid of him. Utley is a potential MVP candidate and you cannot pass off an offer of him. He will give back the stats you traded away with Cabrera and Bruce. So do the trade.

Answer 8

Do it Bruce is going to suck for the rest of the season and you really don't need cabrera

Garland is not that good anyways