Huge Jose Reyes and David Wright trade?

Question

I trade Jose Reyes, and Justin Upton for David Wright

I have Furcal on the DL and can pick up Lugo until furcal returns in a few weeks. I also have a full OF so Upton is my utility guy who i can replace with Longoria. Is this a good trade for me

Answer 1

Take the trade, if the format favours pwoer then Wright is your man. Upton is proving to be distinctly average. much like Carlos Quentin was last year (!).

Evan Longoria is starting to find his way, so will be more valuable IMHO than Upton.

If Lugo is the best option at Short then there are a lot of teams with excess SS, but he'll do in a pinch.

Good trade.

Answer 2

To me, it depends if you need the SB or not.  If so then you need to keep Reyes.  If you have someone else that can still give you a chance of winning that category, then go ahead and trade him and get Wright.