Huge fantasy trade?

Question

he sends

randy moss and vice young

i send him

ladanian tomlinson and jake delhomme

HELP!

Answer 1

The answer is NO.  Randy Moss may look attractive, but LT is far more attractive and will get more touches than Moss.  Remember, LT is a pass catching RB.  So you get the best of both worlds, rushing and receiving.

Delhomme is a decent back up QB as long as he does not re-injure his arm.  Vince Young had his Sophomore blues.  I see more upside with Delhomme despite the injury risk.

I say, don't make a rookie mistake.  

Thumbs up to those who agree.

Answer 2

I wouldn't trade LT alone for those 2. Vince Young hasn't done anything yet, and LT is a stud RB.

Answer 3

no way

Answer 4

First off, don't do it. LT is really good and could rush up to 150 yards per game if he wanted to. Jake Delhomme may be getting older but, he is still an effective QB. I think this is a hard decision because you are both getting Franchise Players and QBs that could both help you. So, I think you should stick with LT and Delhomme.

Answer 5

Red Wings -- hope you didn't pull the trigger and listened to the vast majority of folks advising you to hold off.  Toss me in with those folks.  Tomlinson is a rare commodity and brings unparallel value and stability.  Moss had a career year last year.  The problem with a career year is that a player has no where to go but down.  However, in the "what have you done for me lately" world of fantasy football, value is weighted heavily on the performance in the previous year.  While Moss will have a good year, he won't come close to the year he had last year.  Tomlinson on the other hand can and will continue to do well.  Also, Vince Young is all but a bust, and Delhomme has a load of circumstances surrounding him this year that makes him a sleeper (key additions at WR; successful off-season surgery; "win now" philosophy of management; absolutely no back-up to take job; etc.).

Answer 6

no way...rbs are cornerstone of your team never give up a rb even if it's for the top WR.

Answer 7

Dont do it LT is way to good of a point getter for moss.....

Answer 8

DO IT!!

Answer 9

Vy is weaker than all

Jake isn't what he once was-

SO you are basically trading Ladanian for Moss-

I wouldn't do it --- just because VY is way overrated !!

Answer 10

NO-WAY dude!  Vince Young is an avg. QB at best!  I've got him ranked around #20.  LT is #1 - Moss is@ #5.  I like Delhomme better than Young and think he will have a great come-back year (they have good WRs now in S.Smith, Hackett and Muhammad)

Answer 11

@ mattdean...

RBs can be easily overrated...especially if it's a PPR league. Moss is the best WR out there and Westbrook could replace LT at the top of the RB list.

Depending on points per passing TD, QBs can be easily more valuable than RBs.

It all depends on your scoring system. If you post that, I could help more.

Since passing TDs are only 4 points, their stock drops so you could skate by with a lesser QB. However, if VY is going to be your only option then it may not be worth it. Moss is a top five player and LT could slide this year.

My consensus is if Young is going to be your number one QB, you really need a strong line-up from top to bottom. If you have another option at QB and you have a decent replacement at RB go for it.

Answer 12

no, bad trade.  Running backs are the #1 point getter in ANY fantasy league.  You are trading the BEST player number wise  and a below average QB for a quality wide receiver and a quality QB, but the numbers tomlinson puts up will rival both of those combined.  As long as you have one decent QB on your roster, I wouldn't make this trade.

Answer 13

I wouldn't trade those 3 players TOGETHER for LT. Don't toss your season away.

Answer 14

Dont' do it.  Keep Tomlinson no matter what.  Moss is obviously nice, but not worth giving up your top RB for.  RBs score more points for you than WRs.

Answer 15

Take it you get the better players.  Tomlinson may have a good year, but no promises with Jake Delhomme who's errattic at best in my opinion with Steve Smith and nothing major to speak of.  Young will have a better year than him.

Answer 16

i think if randy moss will hav another great year which i think he will it will still be a bad trade cause jakes a better quarter back then vince. and LT is the number 1 fantasy player ever. so dont do it.

Answer 17

Decline. if you're not crazy. Why would u get rid of L.T for a WR ?