Hypothetical think question - best answer 10 points?

Question

You and five friends of the same s*x and the man/woman of your drems, are on a stranded, remote island with plenty of food, drinking water and resources. You all have lived on the island for 2 years now. As much as you all want to go home, you and your friends will spend the rest of your life on the island.

You have the supernatural power to send the man/woman of your dreams (but you can't send anyone else here or away) back to their city with their job, old life, home, close ones, and better recreation facilities & health care.

No one else knows about this, except you. So no one can resent you for not sending them back.

Would you choose to make them stay with you or to make them go?

Answer 1

Depends on if the person of my dreams wanted to stay.  We have "plenty of food, drinking water and resources."  There's no reason for them to go unless they really want to.  Ask them what they want.  If they love you back and want to stay, then vacation until the end of days.  If they want to go away, then all they are going to do is be resentful for being there and you will become so sick of them in time that you will send them away just so you don't have to look at their miserable face any longer...

If they stay though do be aware that your friends will grow jealous that you have the only man/woman for miles and there will inevitably be squabbles... unless the person of your dreams is very very friendly and you don't mind....

Answer 2

If we both loved each other, I would tell her about my ability to send her back and we would discuss it together. I wouldn't make any rash decisions.

If I loved her but didn't know how she felt about me or knew that she was desperate to return home, then I would definitely send her back--a selfless sacrifice on my part.

Answer 3

stay!!! sorry to that person but we are all happy and are all in it TOGETHER

Answer 4

Stay with me.

Answer 5

If the man/woman of my dreams was content on the island I would not send them home. If they had a family, disparately wanted to go home, or if they would be happier going home I would send them home. If I really cared about that person I would want that person to be happy.