I'm dumping Kevin Curtis from my fantasy team, who's the better pickup? Roddy White or Ted Ginn Jr.?

Question

This should be a slam dunk for Roddy White I would think, but I'm not so sure about he QB situation in ATL. Is Pennington to Ginn a bettter solution?

....without some compelling arguments for Ginn i'm going with White, so you guys have fun....

Answer 1

White has looked pretty good this preseason and is playing with an air of confidence, despite playing for Atlanta.

Ginn is the #1 WR for Miami (actually the only one worth mentioning) and could have a breakout season if Pennington steps up his game. Ginn also returns kicks for TDs. And, in most leagues, you get the points for the TDs, but not the return yardage.

If Ginn comes around as having good fantasy value, I don't think we'll see it for a few weeks. But, White will be a consistent producer from Week 1 on. I would go with White.

Answer 2

pennington has a noodle arm, but is one of the most accurate (completion percentage) QBs in nfl history. despite this, his o-line is bad and theyre going to run the ball alot with sticky icky and ronnie brown anyway. unless your league gives offensive points for return yards/tds then dont pick up ginn.

roddy white is a great, tall receiver that just needs someone to throw him the ball. vick was too busy running around in circles, and matt ryan has the arm to get white the ball.

white all the way.

Answer 3

ugh...slim pickings here, i don't really like either of them...both are number one receivers on really bad teams, but white has proven himself more over the course of his career, and is more dangerous as a deep threat...so even though he's got a rookie quarterback throwing to him, white's gonna get more big plays for sure