I'm re-reading, but Eclipse or Harry Potter 5?

Question

I can't decide which one to re-read.

Someone hep me :)

Answer 1

You could always read Eclipse and watch The Order of the Phoenix. Its not the same I know, but you win!

Answer 2

Ooh! Toughie! I too love both Twilight and HP. But I'd go with Harry Potter 5 first, and then Eclipse.

Answer 3

Harry Potter 5, no doubt about it. I can reread that one over and over and it still never gets old. (That sentence was a bit redundant, wasn't it?) :p

Answer 4

You sound like me.

I'm Halfway through eclipse, and stopped, kind of took a break..

You started Eclipse, you should finish it. But then again The Harry Potter Books are absolutely wonderful. Finish Eclipse then Read OotP

Answer 5

Harry Potter.

Answer 6

HP 5 for sure...

Eclipse was the best Twilight book, but it doesn't even come close to comparing with HP.

Answer 7

It depends...have you already re-read the first 4 harry Potter books because if you did then you should keep going with that one. But since you've already started Eclipse then you might want to finish it first.

I know what you mean about the urge to read Harry Potter lol. I was in the middle of reading Pride and Prejudice and all of a sudden I just HAD to re-read all the HP books. lol. So of course i started reading SS and I finished it in like 5 hours. Now, i'm reading The Lovely Bones and I now want to continue re-reading the HP books. yikes!

Answer 8

Definitely Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix.

It was a long time before I was ale to reread it because it was the darkest book of the series, only bad things happened throughout. Very emotional to read.  

Answer 9

i love them both... but i think you should finish eclipse so you dont have to keep going back and fourth... finish the one you started

Answer 10

Um, I have never read that series. But I am a devoted hp fan. I would suggest go with you gut, or read Eclipse. Trust me, when I read straight through a book, then stop and go on to something else, I get totally confused, and just waste more time.

Isn't Harry potter 5 like 870 or something pages? and Eclipse 500? <( my friend told me) i would read eclipse first, even though i never read it.