I've been offered the following trade. Should I take it?

Question

I Give: Derek Anderson, Santonio Holmes

I Get: Ben Roethlisberger, Donald Driver

Current Team, 10 Team League, Standard Scoring

QB: Derek Anderson

RB: Clinton Portis, Thomas Jones

WR: Randy Moss, Larry Fitzgerald

RB/WR: Santonio Holmes

TE: Dallas Clark

K: Phil Dawson

DEF: Green Bay

BN: Philip Rivers, DeAngelo Williams, Rashard Mendenhall, Santana Moss, Bernard Berrian, Anthony Gonzalez

Answer 1

I say no.  I expect a big year from Holmes.  And Anderson will almost certainly put up better numbers than Ben.

Answer 2

No, Anderson has to much upside

Answer 3

"It is pretty much a tie here. So I would wait a couple of weeks before you finish any type of trade. Big Ben will be good, but not better for sure than Anderson. Although, if you need to know now, I would say keep Anderson, because the Steelers have the toughest scheduele in the league."

Answer 4

Take the trade as fast as you can.