I've been offfered Jason Bay & Michael Bourn for Grady Sizemore and Justin Upton. Should I do it?

Question

I've been offfered Jason Bay & Michael Bourn for Grady Sizemore and Justin Upton. Should I do it?

Answer 1

don't do it. Bourn does nothing but gets SBs. It is hard for him to steal bases because he doesn't get on base enough. Sizemore is hot right now and he will get you SBs, Hits, and HRs. Jason Bay is a good player but i would take sizemore over him and i would take Upton over Bourn.

Answer 2

Personally, I wouldn't do it.  Upton is a young stud and Sizemore will be strong for a while.  The only thing that Sizemore needs to improve is his average.  Keep what you have because Bay has passed his prime and Bourn can only steal bases.

Answer 3

Sizemore is on a struggling team. Jason Bay is aswell, but a much better player. Also Justin Upton really wont do anything big for the next couple years, too young. Take the trade.

Answer 4

If you're giving up Sizemore and Upton then I wouldn't do it.

Sizemore is actually a 30/35 threat this year, even though the Indians are struggling. Upton started off amazing but has definitely cooled off. Bay is rebounding like we've expected. Bourn does nothing but get SB's. His BA is awful and he's not even leading off anymore, so SB's will be harder to come by.

Sizemore > Bay

Upton > Bourn

Hope I helped!

Answer 5

No I would not do it.  Bourn has been on our waiver wire for a week in a 12 team league if that says anything.  Sizemore is a way more solid player than Bay. Bay is decent but he goes through some pretty bad slumps. Sizemore is a second round draft pick....Bay is not.  Upton has a ton of potential, but I'd keep him on  the bench for a while, or maybe just try and trade him away. Keep Sizemore though.