There sure is a lot of rubbish being thrown around here in a way that would imply that it is fact rather than whims.
Guest5462 in particular seems to really be shoveling it. Those who are born in a foreign country to a military family have their U.S. citizenship because the U.S. government allows it as an arrangement for military personnel.
I am a U.S. citizen, born and raised here. But if my child is born in a foreign country, I have to petition the government to adjust their status in the process to make them a U.S. citizen. It is not automatic. If my child was not born on U.S. soil, they are not U.S. a citizen, even though they may be born of "American" parents.
Another thing, Guest5462, a citizen's "descent" is irrelevant. If you look back far enough, you are descended from someone who was not born on U.S. soil. But get real--does anyone go around saying, "I'm American, of British descent" or "I am American, of Norwegian descent"? No, we're Americans. And if someone is a naturalized citizen, they are Americans too. If they were born here, they're Americans.
And Mexico DOES allow dual citizenship, as does Canada, and many other countries. If you are Canadian, and become a U.S. citizen, you do not give up your Canadian citizenship in the eyes of the government there. You do, however, swear at your U.S. citizenship ceremony that you pledge allegiance to the U.S. only, and the U.S. does not recognize the protections or other benefits of your citizenship for any other country.
As for the statement that being born in the U.S. does not make you American, that is flatly not true. If you or born on U.S. soil--at this point in time, anyway-- you are in fact a U.S. citizen. It has been that way for 200+ years, and it is the way than most people become U.S. citizens.
I say "at this point in time" because there are people who would like to change that. They have the "I've got mine" mentality. I see this mostly in 2nd generation immigrants. That is, their parents came from a foreign country and became citizens, they were then born here and thus are U.S. citizens, but they don't want to see anyone else become citizens that way.
I'm not a lawyer, but I've gone through the immigration process with my family and friends over the past 12 years and have picked up a few things. I am the world's expert on my opinion, and much of what I wrote above is just that. This advice is worth exactly what you paid for it. Maybe less...
Report (0) (0) |
earlier