I get Justin Morneau, Michael Young, and Shaun Marcum and I give up Jimmy Rollins and Ryan Dempster. Should I?

Question

I was proposed this trade in my fantasy baseball league. I need some opinions.

Answer 1

Keep J.Roll.

~Good Luck!~

Answer 2

It depends on what you need, rollins gives you stolen bases and runs, young is ok but not up to what Rollins can be. remember the phillies have a fantastic offense led by rollins, and young is just ok to me. First basemen are easier to find on waivers than shortstops. dempster and marcum are a wash but the cubs are a better team, that can lead to more wins for dempster. I say no.

Answer 3

definite yes, Marcum is a great pitcher just his team is not as good as Dempsters so they are closer than they appear.

you get a a top 10 - SS and a top 5 - 1st basemen this is an easy one go and hit accept before the other guy comes to his senses