I got offered either M. Ordonez or Carlos Lee for I. Suzuki. Should I take it, and which one?

Question

I got offered either M. Ordonez or Carlos Lee for I. Suzuki. Should I take it, and which one?

Answer 1

Take Magglio but if you need the speed, keep Ichiro.

Answer 2

I'd take Carlos Lee over Ichiro.  Carlos is good for 35-40 HR, 110 RBI, 100 Runs, and he'll even give you 10 SB accidentally without striking out much.  Magglio could get hot going forward, but all the Tigers have been eh to this point.  Ichiro is going to get on base but his team mates aren't getting him home, and his speed is down as he's getting older.