I have been offerred Chase Utley for Ben Sheets. Should I make the trade?

Question

He's pretty much my ace, but I also have CC Sabathia, Scott Kazmir, Ryan Dempster and Tim Hudson, Jon Lester and Justin Verlander. If I got Utley I could move 2B/OF BJ Upton to my outfield. What would you do?

Answer 1

no ben sheets can give you  better points in the long run i would try and get rid of jon lester and tim hudson for chase utley then you won't have to give up your ace in the hole

Answer 2

Yes,make the trade.You have decent pitching already and you can't go wrong with good hitters.Utley is hitting 23 Hr's this year and just short of a .300 average. Verlander will come around this year and C.C with play very well in the second half of the season.

Answer 3

Definitely take it, thats a steal.

Answer 4

h**l yeah cause you know Sheets still has one more DL stint this year

Answer 5

make the trade-

even on a slumping Philly team, Utley is a premier player.

Sheets has had durability issues and I think you have enough at SP to overcome the loss

Answer 6

Retarded (ri-ˈtär-dəd) - slow or limited in intellectual or emotional development or academic progress.

1.  The other team is retarded for wanting to trade Utley for Sheets.

2.  This is a retarded question!  Of course, you want Utley.

3. Jon Lester and Tim Hudson for Utley!  Retarded!  No one would trade Lester and Hudson for Utley...if they were smart!  

4.  Sheets to amass more points than Utley?  Now that's just  straight up retarded!