I just traded nick markakis and andy petite for jason bay. good or bad?

Question

I just traded nick markakis and andy petite for jason bay. good or bad?

Answer 1

I would say bad unless you have really good pitching. Sorry.

Answer 2

insanely bad trade

Answer 3

terrible trade

Answer 4

Not to hurt your feelings, but this trade probably didn't help much at all. Markakis and Bay are about equal in rank, but Markakis is starting to heat up and gain momentum while Bay is slowing down. Pettitte is also starting to heat up and pitch better despite his old age. This trade wasn't absolutely terrible and won't wreck your team, so it's a good idea to just forget about it and move on. Good luck the rest of the season.

Answer 5

Terrible trade. How did it help you in any way? You gave up a great outfielder and a quality starter for a good outfielder. You weakened yourself in pitching, and in hitting. Congrats.