I need a third string QB. Who is a safer pick? Chad Pennington or Kyle Orton?

Question

Two starting QBs in the league

Answer 1

I would go with Pennington, his job looks safer right now.  Kyle might be the starter, but who knows how long it will be before Lovie switches QB's again

Answer 2

Neither one is a very attractive option.  Pennington has low arm strength, but he is a veteran and shouldn't throw too many INTs. Orton is young and has a higher upside, but he will probably have INT issues.  

Given the choice, I'd probably go with Pennington.  Miami has a decent running game which should give Pennington some open passing lanes.

Chicago has an Inexperienced QB and running game and that scares me away from Orton

Answer 3

Both offenses stink but Id go with Pennington, hes more of a passer than orton, he gets the job done and has the experience with better wr's.  

Answer 4

chad cuz he is a starter

under no pressure

and just wants to win

Answer 5

tough but i  would go with pennington since he doesnt really bomb the ball he has one of the best completion percentages in football history actually just because he uses the small routes more than takin a risk downfield because of his arm. Hes the safer pick.