I need some feedback on a design

Question

Im working on a layout for a band and in the layout there is going to be a planet. I have never made a planet before in photoshop and today i messed around with it a little and i came up with this

http://tinypic.com/usermedia.php?uo=daKCD/zuMR6EitALEsvBkg==

for some reason it looks kinda funny to me but i want to see what everybody else thinks

please be honest, and not say it looks good unless you actually mean it

thanks!

Answer 1

I think this is pretty good! The only thing I can see that looks a little odd is the center and right where you have some nearly vertical lines, and then that sort of large diagonal patch that reminds me almost of paint that's been scraped. Maybe there's just too much detail there? The edges on the left curve of the planet seem to indicate an atmosphere, but these lines and scraped patch are too clear, they should maybe show some blurring. The nearly straight vertical lines look too flat; you'd expect to see a slight bend in them as they go around the planet.

But overall I like it a lot!

Answer 2

That's actually pretty good! There's some pixelization around the edges, but I think it may just be my computer...

Answer 3

Thats a pretty good planet....No joke........it looks like a planet that no one has ever discovered 4 reals...and i dont lie..........

Answer 4

I think it's very good, you should be proud of your planet and I went to art college so I should know. Hmmmmmmm......

Answer 5

thats a pretty good planet, and im serious. but u added a bit too much streaks and features, looks kinda fake. and also, is it suppose to b a made up planet or an actual planet like mars or something? if its made up, not bad. but if its a planet.............u might wanna google some pictures of that planet and start over.......