I need to add a catcher to catch up on games in my roto league. Who should I take?

Question

The best available catchers are Jason Varitek, Ramon Hernandez and Yadier Molina. Varitek seems like the best choice to me, since the slump he's in can't last forever, but I'm not confident enough to pick him up until I get some other opinions. Any help is appreciated!

Answer 1

I would go with Yadier Molina.    He's younger than other 2.

Answer 2

I think you should take Molina for now, because he's the one that's doing best right now, but then take Varitek later when he's doing well. Hernandez is really struggling. Since I wouldn't risk using getting Varitek, in case he still struggles, I'd get Molina.

Answer 3

Varitek has never put up good fantasy numbers. Yad has improved at the plate this year as he did last year, plus he catches almost every day. Hernandez has just had problems this year.

So I agree that Molina is the way to go.

Good luck. Have fun.