I was just offered Miguel Cabrera, Alex Rios and Roy Halliday for Matt Holliday and Justin Duchscherer. ???

Question

My team has been in the top 3 all season but ive been winless for the past few weeks, dropping me to 5th...out of 12. I have dan haren, cliff lee, ervin santana for some bright spots in pitching but my hitting is weak. besides a-rod, all i have is holliday, a shaky jeter and sizemore. The guy who is offering me these guys is in last.

Answer 1

I say do it because Alex Rios cannot stay in the slump that he is in and then Miguel Cabrera is a great player and I promise you he will pick it up by the All-Star Game. Then Halliday is having a good year and is a Cy Young winner unlike Justin Duchscherer will not keep up his dominance. Matt Holliday will be hard to let go but trust me you will get the better deal.

Answer 2

every one is on the money on this one. he is trying to buy low for holliday cuz he just got back and doesnt have the stats that some other players do. and although i like halliday, duchscherer is way to valuable right now to sell him for one ok pitcher. no way, tell him that u can see what his trying to do and u wont trade holliday for anything less than full value

Answer 3

DECLINE!!!! because Matt Holliday is studmuffin and Roy gets no Ks and Rios is a bust and JD is lights OUT!!!

Answer 4

I like this trade for you.Cabrera and Rios have the potential to power your team through the fantasy playoffs,and Halliday and Dutch is pretty even.Rios WILL boost your steals,and Cabrera will boost your power.Also there's a chance Holliday

will be traded,playing away from Coors field will effect his stats negatively.(Think about the playoffs,if your league has one.That's where you get hardware(or software),3 years from now you prob. wont remember winning the regular season...

But you'll always see that trophy from winning the playoffs.

~Good Luck!~