I was offered Rudi Johnson and Larry Fitzgerald for my Joseph Addai and Roy Williams. Should I accept?

Question

I don't really see how this trade would improve my team, so I'm leaning towards rejecting it. But what do you think?

My Team - 12 Team H2H League

QB - Carson Palmer

RB - Joseph Addai

RB - Darren McFadden

WR - Donald Driver

WR - Roy Williams

RB/WR - Laveranues Coles

TE - Kellen Winslow

K - Shane Graham

DST - Ravens

Bench

Jason Campbell

Adrian Peterson (the other one)

Leon Washington

Santana Moss

Benjamin Watson

Answer 1

I prefer Addai and Roy Williams.  Williams is a repectable WR even if Fitzgerald is better.  They key here is that Rudi Johnson sounds like chopped liver to me.  I really like Addai in the Colts offense.  I have Addai as a top 5 back and the best player in this deal.  Hang onto the best player when in doubt.

Answer 2

Yeah, don't do the trade.  But you have serious other problems:  McFadden a starter?  Why am I seeing all these teams w/ him as a starter?  Fargas will start for Oak. and McFadden will work into a platoon situation later in the year - maybe getting 10-12 carries a game.  Who are your backup RBs?  Leon will touch the ball 6-7x a game.  Peterson probably won't play at all!  (Chi. now has Forte AND Kevin Jones)  Upgrade your RBs!

Answer 3

joseph addai is a top5 caliber running back. rudi johnson is at the end of his prime. larry fitz sounds nice, but you can't afford to lose addai. you were right. reject the trade.

Answer 4

Don't do it because the Lions are reshaping their O-line so Kitna won't get dropped on his @$$ so many times which means more looks for Roy and Rudi Johnson is nowhere as good as Joseph Addai is..

Answer 5

no no no

Answer 6

Don't do it....Addai will score more points by himself than Rudi, Larry, and Roy combined.