I work in Manhattan (Gramercy/Flatiron), should I live in Staten Island or in the City?

Question

Given both rental prices are the same: Should I live in Staten Island and enjoy a higher quality of living (nicer, larger spot) but bit the bullet with a longer commute (SI Ferry + Subway), or should I live in NYC in a shoe-box size apt and take the short commute (Subway)....btw if you can also tell me what the commute TIME is from St. George SI to Madison Square Park (20's and madison) in the city, you're guaranteed 10 points!

Answer 1

u should live in staten island

i live there

it is great

its calm and not stressing

u have a less chance of getting robbed

staten island is more safe more relaxing and who would want to live in a box sized apartment

Answer 2

I've been to NYC many times (I live in Colorado).  If I were to select a place to live, I would probably live in Queens.  The commute on thee Staten Island Ferry and SI subway and then another subway ride in the city takes forever.  

Queens is out of the fast pace mess of Manhattan but is still easily accessible to the subway system.  Staten Island is quieter and has more room but it would be the long commute that would deter me.  

Being a 4th generation resident of Colorado, where we have open space, clear mountain views, and fresh air, I don't envy the decision you have to make....