IO DVR or Tivo HD DVR?

Question

which one is better?

is there any point in getting a Tivo if you already have IO, since you have to pay for service + the Tivo itself?

Answer 1

IO DVR:  Store up to 100 hours of Standard Definition Television programming and 24 hours of HD programming! (IO DVR) If you are recording in HD that is sad hours to record..

The Tivo:

Save up to 20 hours of HD programming (or 180 hours of standard definition) at one timeRecord two shows at once**Works with cable and antenna; does NOT support satelliteUse CableCARD decoders from your cable company to replace your cable boxSupports high definition TV (This is also sad if you want to record in HD)..

Directv HD DVR: Record up to 200 hours of SD programming, up to 50 hours of HD programming. (Ok, not bad)..

DishNetwork: Record up to 350 hours of standard-definition (SD), up to 55 hours of high-definition (HD) entertainment or a combination of the two (Pretty Good)

Answer 2

Tivo hd dvr!!! Tivo is like a gift from the lords to re-wind to the good parts...and record things!!!