If Jim Edmonds reaches 400 career homeruns, along with his spectacular defense, will it be enough for the HOF?

Question

If Jim Edmonds reaches 400 career homeruns, along with his spectacular defense, will it be enough for the HOF?

Answer 1

Jim Edmonds is not a Hall of Famer.  

Answer 2

No way!!

Answer 3

3rd or forth ballot if he makes it but i doubt it

Answer 4

Good question....if it was up to me then YES! But it's not so when you find out let me know!

Answer 5

I think with 400 HRs and his 'D,' he's got a good sporting chance. My question is if he gets in, will he wear an

Angels

Cardinals

Padres (yeah right)

or Cubs hat?

I think he should wear the Cardinals hat. World series champ, longest he's been with any team in his career, (7 yrs). 4th most home runs as a Cardinal in franchise history (241), most of his 8 Gold Gloves as a Cardinal.

Answer 6

I think he will be in the Hall, but it's going to be a long time before he gets inducted, as of today he has 377 homers, .286 lifetime BA, and he also has 8 gold gloves. He was both an offensive and defensive force in his prime. I kinda see him as a poor man's Willie Mays...without the speed of course.

Answer 7

i  wish oh and btw are u a card or cub fan

becuz if u like the cubs then u are luky to have him but if u like the cards then he done alot for us

Answer 8

I think it's too soon to assume he'll hit 400 home runs. I don't think he'll reach that point though. Outside of his defense, no other stats really stand out to make him a HoF'er. 500 Hr used to be an automatic bid for the HOF, but after seeing a 2007 season where we saw A-Rod, Thome,  and Big Hurt reach 500 HR, some people think the value of a HR has diminished. I just don't see 400 making the cut for Edmonds. Another reason is that it might be a little hard to come up with reasons for him to go in the HOF,  but easier to make a case against it.

Answer 9

I don't think so.

Answer 10

nope

Answer 11

I hope so.  He has a lot of gold gloves, and was a postseason hero.  But if your just a hopeful cub fan who wants to beef up their hall of fame list, Edmonds is all but certain to go in with the cardinals if it happens.

Answer 12

No

sorry

but A good player