If Richmond got Judd, would that change your opinion on the clubs success?

Question

It seems to have made no difference in peoples opinion of the club since Carlton recruiting him.

Answer 1

Carlton and Richmond are teams that struggle to make it near the top 8 so it basically won't make much difference if Judd switches over to Richmond unless Richmond gets a wake up call and starts to get a winning streak hopefully enough to ensure a spot in the finals in 2008

Answer 2

Richmond is so messed up that Judd would have been very frustrated and been able to contribute very little (the old one man side story). He may win the ball after a ruck contest, but how to get it to Richo would be almost impossible.

Just my opinion.

Answer 3

No, it would not change my opinion.

Another multiple ID I see .... and not hard to gues who it belongs to!

Answer 4

If Richmond had got Judd my opinion of their chances would still be the same bottom of the ladder, I think Carlton will push for a top 8 position this year, I don't support them, I support the Dee's and I think we will finish bottom 3.

Clone hunter? are you real or one of these multiple accounts this one person has, by your question I tend to believe you might be the real McCoy, if you are a real new account forgive us as there has been a lot of c**p going on in here with one person using multiple accounts and cloning others, but I guess you know that as evidenced by your avatar name.

Answer 5

I dont think Judd would be enough to help Richmond out either to be honest.  They need to change their game play and strengthen their midfield so that Richo gets a chance at goals!!

Answer 6

Richmond didn't get Judd, he is at Carlton end of story !   What ever you are trying to suggest is irrelevant.