If Roddick and Blake were to play each other in a match, who do you think would win?

Question

If Roddick and Blake were to play each other in a match, who do you think would win?

Answer 1

andy roddick. serve is better and he's more consistent.

Answer 2

both very disapointing players.. with limited games..

but i would pick Andy Roddick... better serve...

Answer 3

It would depend on the surface.  I think it would be close, but I would give Roddick the nod on grass, and it would be a toss up on all of the other surfaces.

Answer 4

Absolutely no question whatsoever... Andy Roddick. 6-0, 6-0, 6-0 (Just kidding!!!!)

Answer 5

Well going by their career head-to-head , in which Roddick leads 6-2, you'd have to go with Roddick, although it wouldn't be shocking if Blake won.  Most of their matches have been pretty close.

Answer 6

andy roddick.

i love blake but he's not consistent with his shots.

Answer 7

Andy Roddick I think has the edge.  No matter the playing surface.  James Blake chokes even more than Roddick.  Which seems impossible.

Answer 8

Andy Roddick

Answer 9

roddick

Answer 10

Roddick would win. He is the best american male player, he has the overall results to prove it as well as leading all the other American male players in thier head to heads.

Answer 11

If both were playing well (which is rare these days), then it depends on the surface.

Grass- Roddick wins (Roddick is a two time Wimbledon finalist and a 4 time Queens Champion). Blake has never won a tournament on Grass nor made if very far at Wimbledon.

Clay- Blake wins (Roddick sucks on clay and Blake is the only American male with a snowball's chance in h**l of doing well at the French Open)

Hardcourt- It really depends on how long the match is. In a best of 3, Blake wins because he has more variety to his game and more weapons than Roddick who is one dimensional. In a best of 5, Roddick wins because he has more experience at handling that kind of pressure and is much more consistent over the course of a match than Blake is.