If a sunni is someone who follows the right Islam & right sunnah, does that make the shia sunnis?

Question

...like an ahl-ul bayt sunni?

Answer 1

My friend first of all does the shias follow the sunnah of the prophet(P B U H)this is my question to u.

Answer 2

No it makes shias not sunnis because they dont :)

You didnt really have to ask this just use your brain

EDIT : EVIWAHABI

Abu bakr and umar (r.a) and the followers of the prophet u fool, so even if u say we follow them, its the same thing.....

Anyway, we follow the prophet muhammad (s.a.w.s) unlike u

Answer 3

sunnis think only they are following right authentic sunnah..

in fact they are the ones who started present day shahadah,

told them by abu hurairah

how come they reject the CLEAR VERSE 3:18

which is THE TRUE SHAHADAH

Answer 4

The problem with shiaa mainly  is the innovations , one hadith is saying that who innovates something that is not in Islam then he is not from us .

I believe they are no different from sunnis because both are following hadiths but different set of it .

Answer 5

the problem is ,what Sunnah do shias follow?

the answer is"khomaini's sunnah"

Answer 6

The term "Sunni" is short for "Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jama'3a (The people of the Sunnah and the community)" while the term "Shia" is short for "Shiat Ali (party of Ali)". A Muslim who follows the Sunnah is Sunni, simple as that. So a Shia who follows the sunnah is a Sunni as well (though they both have different opinions on what the Sunnah really is, so it would be a different kind of Sunni). A Sunni can never be a Shia because they do not believe Ali (ra) was supposed to be the first Caliph. And I am not sure what you mean by Ahlul Bayt Sunni? Ahlul Bayt are "people of the house". Sunnis and Shiis have different opinions on who falls under that category. Either ways, both Sunnis and Shias argue that they are following the right "Sunnah" even though they are different from one another. A Sunni and a Shias definition of what the Sunnah is differentiates. Technically every sect of Islam is a Sunni since they believe they are following the Sunnah. But being called a Sunni puts everyone else under the category of "Sunni" and not Shia, Ahmadi, Ismaeeli, etc. So they prefer to be called the "true" Muslims or just go by the term that was given/chosen for/by their sect.

To Mia:

Sunnis follow Muhammad (pbuh). Ali (ra) followed Muhammad (pbuh). Therefor they as Ali (ra) follow the prophet. They do not follow Ali (ra), AbuBakr (ra), Omar (ra), or Uthman (ra), all just follow the prime example: Muhammad (pbuh).

To Eviwahhabi:

What!? Do you even know what you're talking about? In which Sunni books does it show that Ali (ra) rejected the Sunnah of Omar and AbuBakr? And it's not their Sunnah, it's the prophet's Sunnah that they all follow. You read!

Answer 7

That's correct. The Shia are followers of the Quran and Sunnah and if someone who does that is called a "Sunni" then we are Sunni, but Sunni is a created word for the devient Sunni sect so we prefer to be called Muslims. We differ with our Sunni brothers on the origin of the hadiths in that we take hadiths primarily from the purifyed Ahlulbayt (AS) and the sahabah, while they take them from any sahabi but ignore the Ahlulbayt.

Answer 8

To eviwahh

"The bedouins say: "We believe."Say:"You believe not but you only say,'We have surrendered(in Islam),'for Faith has not yet entered your hearts.But if you obey Allah and His Messenger (SAW),He will not decrease anything in reward for your deeds. Allah is oft-Forgiving , Most Merciful."[Qur'an , 19:14]

Why are you twisting the Qur'an? Do you thought that others won't notice that?

We are only Follower of Qur'an and authentic Sunnah of prophet(pbuh). We Respect&Love  Ali(ra) More than that you shia do.

Christian too claim that they Love Jesus Christ (pbuh).but they not in truth.Same way ,neither you people Love & Respect Ali(ra).

______________________________________...

This verse even explode you shia sayings. Shia never gonna follow the Islam.because They are the Enemy of Islam.

They Label and Claim as Muslim&Mumins but they are NOT.They Follow Shiaism NOT Islam.They actually want to finish us but they will never success.they were the reason for the division of Islam.They are one of the BIGGEST Hypocrites of this Ummah.

Ahlelbayts(r.a) has nothing to do with Shiaism as Jesus Christ(pbuh) has nothing to do with Christianity.

______________________________________...

@ Rumaitha رميثاء רומית'א ,

Jama'ah simply doesn't mean the community.

Its an Meaningful word. even only person can be Jama'ah.

'Amro bin Maymoon said to 'Abdullaah ibn Mas'ood (رضي الله عنه):

وكيف لنا بالجماعة؟

((So how are we with the Jamaa'ah?))

So Ibn Mas'ood replied to 'Amro:

يا عمرو بن ميمون إنَّ جمهور الجماعة هي التي تفارق الجماعة، إنما الجماعة ما وافق طاعة الله وإن كنت وحدك

((O 'Amro bin Maymoon, the majority of the Jamaa'ah are those who differ with the Jamaa'ah, indeed the Jamaa'ah are those who are firm upon the obedience of Allaah even if you are by yourself)) (Reported by al-Laalikaa'ee in his Sharh Usool al-I'tiqaad (160) and by Ibn 'Asaakir in his Taareekh Dimashq (2/322/13))

We are called as Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jama'ah , because we are in  the true Path & obedience to Allah & we are following  the True Teaching of Allah's Messenger.