Question:

If ab, ac and bc are perfect cube, prove a,b,c are also perfect cube.?

by Guest64834  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

If ab, ac and bc are perfect cube, prove a,b,c are also perfect cube.?

 Tags:

   Report

2 ANSWERS


  1. Proof by contradiction:

    Suppose ab, ac, bc are all cubes and not all of a, b, c are.

    Consider the prime factors of a, b, c.

    Since we suppose a is not a cube, then at least one of its prime factors

    does not occur a multiple of 3 times.

    That prime factor must occur either 3n+1 or 3n+2 times, for some n.

    But ab is a cube, so that same factor much occur 3m+2 or 3m+1 times in b,

    since all factors in ab occur a multiple of three times.

    Let's say the factor occurs 3n+1 times in a and 3m+2 times in b.

    (if not, just switch a and b)

    That same factor must occur either 3j, 3j+1, or 3j+2 times in c.

    In any of those cases, it prevents ac or bc or both from being cubes,

    which is a contradiction.

    Thus all prime factors must occur 3k times in all of a, b, and c,

    and they are all perfect cubes.

    .


  2. That's only three sides.  Which would make a triangle, not a cube.  If you're gonna ask us to do your homework, at least get the problem correct.

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 2 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.