If atree falls in the forest and there"s nobody around to hear it does it still make a noise.?

Question

If atree falls in the forest and there"s nobody around to hear it does it still make a noise.?

Answer 1

My wife likes this variation:

If a man speaks in the forest and there is no woman around to hear him, is he still wrong?

Ha!

Answer 2

yes, but nobody will be there to hear it.

Answer 3

If noise is defined by air vibrating within certain

frequencies, sure.

If noise is defined BY SOMEBODY HEARING IT, no.

However, I have never heard anyone use the latter

definition other than when asking this very question.

Of course it makes a noise.

Answer 4

Yes.  Noise exists whether there is a hearer or not.   Air waves carry the sound across the vicinity. Only is outer space is it soundless.

Answer 5

what an arrogant Christian question

as if Humans are the only things alive that count .

this question should be reported for exstreme rascism against the animal populations .

the forrest are full of beings who can smell see and hear ,much better than Humans can

go stand in the corner

Answer 6

I'm sure the squirrels and the birds would hear it.

Answer 7

if their is no one around how do you know if a tree fall.