If people lived by the zodiac what do you think the world would be like?

Question

do you think we would be at peace or more chaotic. and do you really think everyone born around the same zodiac would be alike. what would make them different?

Answer 1

An astrology reading does not tell anybody what to do... ideally it offers guidance and suggestions... the world will still be the world as it is... maybe flowing a little bit more smoothly...

Answer 2

It would actually be chaotic.  If you were planning a vacation somewhere, 1/12 of everyone would be there.  Looking around in this world, how could you believe there is only 12 personalities?  You meet a dozen people and one of them could be a duplicate of you?  If it was that easy to meet a compatible person, why isn't it?

You are shaped by your family, your experiences, and your understanding of all that.

So 1/12 of all kinds of people, good and bad forced into the same place at the same time, because the horoscope said so would sure to bring chaos.

Answer 3

The things that would make them different would be the same things that make people different today: they'd all have completely unique experiences of life(being in different times and places with different things happening around and to them), and they'd grow to expect different things out of life and behave differently because of that.

That's one of the soundest arguments there *is* for zodiacal determinism being pure nonsense.

Answer 4

I would hate that. If that was the case, you could just ASK someone their birthday and you'd know all about them. Don't you think it would get just a LITTLE boring? I don't like the concept of "what you see is what you get". I'd like to think that people are more than their signs, though its certainly fun to read about =)