If some one is in your face and acts like he is about to sucker punch you is it legal to hit him first?

Question

it is for NY state

Answer 1

If you feel threatened and you strike first, you can try to make a case for self defense.  It's less likely to hold up without being accosted first though.  Consider though that striking first is likely to provoke a response, and if this person were to attack back, they clearly have a case of self defense.

Answer 2

negative it is still not considered self defensive motive.

Answer 3

I think, if you feel you are in imminent danger of being assaulted, you have the right to defend yourself. That's what I think, anyway.

Answer 4

If he looks like he is about to then I think it is not legal, but if he actullay come like 2 inches infront of your face with a mean face and not a funny face then it is considered self-defense.  If he comes with a weapon with a not funny face then you can punch the guy

Answer 5

In NY you would be required to walk away.  No, you cannot hit him.

Answer 6

Nope....you cant strike someone without them striking you first.  By the way its not a sucker punch if he is standing right in front of you and you can see his every movment.

Answer 7

That depends on your state law. Some allow you to stand your ground, others have a duty to retreat. In all states, self defense is an "affirmative defense". That means it is up to you to prove you had the right to use it.

Answer 8

Sounds like self defense to me.   In Texas  one can protect his self and property to the hilt should he feel his life and goods are in danger.

I would consider anyone wanting to throw a punch at me, would be putting  me in grave danger.  And just might need to take care of that sucker by slapping the ....you know what out of him or grabbing him and laying him flat out on the ground.  I would not let someone sucker punch me without a really dog fight.

Answer 9

Here in Florida it is

Its called the " stand your ground" law  

Answer 10

if he throws the first punch then it is legal to punch him back dat would b self defense oh and try to doge the first punch  

Answer 11

No.  It isn't legal to hit someone first unless they have a weapon or it is clear beyond any doubt they are about to attack you.