If someone is born as man and get a s*x change to look like a woman do u consider them to be a man or a woman?

Question

after the operation or vice versa?

just curious

Answer 1

If a man was to tell me that they felt like they were meant to be a woman and was going to live as a woman I would respect that and refer to them as she ans call them female.  (with or without an opperation!)

I am a L*****n and I can't expect a straight person to understand.

I have dyslexia and ADD, but I do not expect someonewithout these conditions to understand.

I do not have gender issues, but I am happy to accept other peoples judgments about their own minds and bodies.

Answer 2

If 'someone is born a man and get a s*x change to look like a woman', then he's a man.

If someone is born transsexual and  'get a s*x change to look like a woman', she's a woman.

Gender is determined in the brain, not in the genitals.

Answer 3

I consider them to be what they want to be.  Regardless of the operation, if someone identifies as the opposite s*x, it is respectful to refer to them as such.

Answer 4

She's a woman.  Not her fault her body was born male.

Besides, if she's transitioned fully, she will look like a woman in every way, and most times you would never know her birth history.

Answer 5

They are whatever they are living as, saying anything else is just rude to them.

Answer 6

man because thats originally how they were created

Answer 7

a woman

Answer 8

She is a she.

If you call her he, SHE will tell you different.

Technically, Trans-gendered, male to female.

Answer 9

i would say they are a man =S

Answer 10

God made him a man and no matter what he does he will always be a man. It not just parts that make you what you are. Its God.

Answer 11

they are whatever they tell me they are. it doesnt matter if they have had the operation or not

Answer 12

Transwomen are women, have always been women, and deserve just as much respect as anyone else.

They are women before transition, during transition, and after transition, and anyone who says otherwise can kiss my ***.

Answer 13

If they still carry the "Y" chromosome, they're still a man!

Answer 14

i would say they are a woman, since they has a s*x change so by definition they are not male anymore...

Answer 15

well then i guess they are a woman :)

Answer 16

If they decide to be a woman, then i consider them a woman.

Answer 17

whcih ever one they want to be called.. most likely women

Answer 18

i consider them as a women  

Answer 19

If someone lives and dresses as a woman, I would be respectful and accept that person as a woman. I think transgendered people have a tough enough time already without people being rude about them.

Answer 20

To be respectful, I consider them whatever they consider themselves to be.

If they believe they are a woman, then who Am I argue;) More power to em;)

Answer 21

I call them Bob-er-a.

Answer 22

I think she is a woman, whether or not she has completed her surgery or not.

Answer 23

yup, she's a woman!

Answer 24

a female.

To the answerer who stated "Y" chromosomes mean male...get an education. If you think you've had one, think again.

Answer 25

I would say they were a woman if they believed they were a woman, &I would say they were a man if they believed they were a man.