If u could only choose one, who would you pick: Johan Santana or CC Sabathia?

Question

If u could only choose one, who would you pick: Johan Santana or CC Sabathia?

Answer 1

Johan Santana...

Answer 2

CC

Answer 3

CC Sabathia. Santana's not getting any help from the bullpen, and Sabathia has been lights out with the Brewers.

Answer 4

CC for sure.

Answer 5

For right now CC, for longterm, Johan.

Answer 6

CC SABATHIA!!!

Answer 7

CC is younger and has better numbers.. So CC

Answer 8

johan santana. hoever i would not pick him with the mets bullpen. they always blow his lead

Answer 9

Easily Johan. Hes amazing and already has two cy youngs and is a dominant strike out pitcher with great win totals and great ERA totals. Only reason he'll only win 15 games is because his bullpen sucks badly.

Answer 10

my man cc sabathia is better s***w johan he sucks im from wisconsin and cc's gonna be a great he's the man u cant top him he can take out any hitter NO DOUBT ABOUT IT!!!!

Answer 11

Sabathia.  No taint of Flushing.

Answer 12

Both of them are great pitchers but I'd take Sabathia he's younger and his ERA is lower.

Answer 13

right now..........CC

Answer 14

CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC...

HE WILL EAT UP MY INNININGS

Answer 15

ok so it's obvious that all these people that answered Santana are from New York because I don't know how you would choose Santana over CC, that's just dumb. CC has a 1.59 era in the NL right now and hasn't lost a game since coming over, how do you not choose him?

Answer 16

Johan Santana.

No Doubt.

Sabathia is Very Nice Pitcher.

But if I had to Choose one Pitcher in a 1 Game Series I Choose Santana.

Answer 17

Johan Santana

Answer 18

Johan Santana.  How much longer can CC cart all that weight around and still be effective?