If you could see any player in VFL/AFL history play on each other, who would it be?

Question

My choice would be Mal Brown v Barry Hall, Gary Ablett Snr v Peter Knights, Diesel Williams v Chris Judd.

Answer 1

Barry Hall vs Warrick Capper

Now that would be funny =)

Answer 2

Chris Grant vs Whitten, with either at CHF or CHB

Answer 3

FEVOLA ON SILVANGI

Answer 4

i would like to see the triple brownlow medallists hayden bunton and d**k reynolds play against one another, h**l!, i'd be happy just to see them play at all

Answer 5

Id see Ablett VS Ablett Jr.

Answer 6

Yep Muir on Libba and Ablett v Ablett.... omg this would be fantastic to watch!

Answer 7

Alex Jezalenco Vs Dale Thomas

and

Malcom Blight Vs Jonathon Brow

Answer 8

Ablett snr vs Ablett jnr

ooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Answer 9

Buddy Franklin vs Steven Silvagni,

Scarlett vs Locket,

Dunstall vs  Leo Barry,

Bradshaw one on one with Brown,

Haydyn Buntun vs Judd.

Answer 10

Gary Ablett Snr -Vs- Gary Ablett Jnr.

Would Snr stick the dirt into Jnr as he did to anyone else who got the better of him?

Who can forget the grand final where he charged Dipper from behind when Dipper was contesting a mark. Ablett hit him with a lowered shoulder, not looking at the ball, & didn't go for the ball.

Dipper suffered a punctured lung because of it. In today's game Ablett would have copped at least 8 weeks for the incident.

Answer 11

i'd say Nathan Buckley vs. Michael Voss they've already played but yeaaa taht would be awsome seeing them again and Gary Ablett snr vs. Gary Ablett jnr see which Ablett is the better of the two

Answer 12

Ohhh. Interesting Question.

Gary Ablett Snr. VS Bruce Doull.

Gary Ablett Jnr. VS Jimmy Bartel.

Brendan Fevola VS Barry Hall (switching positions every quarter)

Answer 13

Haydn Bunton Sr vs Chris Judd - the two greatest players of all-time.

Answer 14

I would like to see

Tony Libratore V Josh Carr.

Maurice Rioli V Dale Thomas

Bruce Doull V James Hird.

Answer 15

**I'd like to see Gary Ablett Snr play on Matthew Scarlett.**

Answer 16

"Mad Dog" Robbie Muir on Tony Libaratore.

Muir would not put up with the scragging by that dirty little sod & would flatten him in the first quarter.

One of my fondest memories is seeing Libba sitting on the interchange bench with an eye the size of a duck egg. A little bit of evening up had just taken place out on the ground. I forget who the Dogs were playing that day.

Answer 17

Mine favorite would be Ben Cousins vs Chris Judd, both being past eagles captains, i would love to see how they would go on each other. who would win? and how they would treat each other?

Would of loved to have seen it in the eagles vs Carlton game this year.. but that wasn't to be!

and I would be cheering for Cuzzy!!

Answer 18

Some good match ups there,  i think Judd would of run Williams off his legs.

brown and hall, wow, those two would just go at it early i reckon.

My fave player   Royce Hart  playing on  Steven Silvagni,  both great ground players, great leaps, with todays rules, Silvagni would be in big trouble, even in the old rules, when the ball hit the ground, Royce was cat like in his reflexes. great duel.