If you had SB's to give and needed HR's and RBI, would you trade away Carl Crawford for J.D Drew?

Question

If you had SB's to give and needed HR's and RBI, would you trade away Carl Crawford for J.D Drew?

Answer 1

Not the best choice. Drew can be inconsistent with those homers and RBI's. Crawford is pretty good. I'd try Milton Bradley.

Answer 2

I would hang on to Crawford.  Once Ortiz returns he is going to bump Drew out of the three hole.  I would expect his numbers to drop when he doesn't have Manny lurking behind him.  Pedroia is locked into the second slot so unless Francona has him lead off (not likely) he is probably going to drop down to 6-7th.

Answer 3

I would trade Crawford anyways.  I have benched him for the time being.  He is not getting any steals anyways because of his bad hamstring.  J.D. is overrated anyways.

Answer 4

Not in a million years, J.D Drew could get injured at anytime and is very inconsistant. I'd either keep Crawford or try and trade him for a productive outfielder.