If you had read twilight, this question is really interesting and not answered... ?

Question

if you did read it... you see that edward is perfect caring a everything right??? ok so here is the question

WHO WAS THE ONE THAT PUT THE CHAINS IN THE CAR OF BELLA, WHEN IT WAS SNOWING?

who remembers this part of the story?

Answer 1

it was charlie but maybe it was really edward and she just thought it was charlie

you have a really good point here

Answer 2

Her dad did, charlie. it even says it in the book. hmm let me check... page 55 of twilight. read it.

Answer 3

she says it was charlie?

Answer 4

I don't even remember that part. I used to be good at this kind of things... God, i'm getting old at 17... Real 17 not like edward's

Answer 5

Bella said Charlie put the snow chains on. That's why she was staring at them, and almost got ran over-- she wasn't used to being taken care of by a parent, because she always took care of Renee.

At least Bella thinks it was Charlie. We can't be completely sure because we, as readers, are limited to Bella's point of view in Twilight. I guess we'll find out for sure in Midnight Sun, though I think we'll find it was Charlie (though I wish it were Edward.)

Answer 6

Charlie

Answer 7

Yea, since Bella was shocked by the parental act of kindness theres a chance it could have been Edward but i'd never really thought of it that way - good question

Answer 8

Charlie did.

I don't think Edward really decided to be over protective until the car accident that happened later in that chapter.

Answer 9

omg i never thought of that either charlie or edward. that is an awsome question!!

Answer 10

Bella woke up to a frozen Forks, and was discouraged before she headed off to school. She was especially careful on the road because she knew the ground was so slippery, but she realized she was having no trouble at all. She parked carefully, anyways, at her school, then went to investigate. She found snow chains diamond-crossed on her truck's tires. Charlie, she thought. She was used to taking care of Renee, and was not used to being looked out for, therefore touched by his concern.

Then Tyler slipped with his car and nearly killed Bella, with Vampire Edward coming to Superman the Day.

Answer 11

it was charlie.

Answer 12

It was charlie b4 he went to work.

Answer 13

charlie did before he left to go to work- bella thinks it was nice of him

Answer 14

Since the second time I read the book I've wondered the same exact thing and it drvies me mad.  I think it was Edward but we'll find out in Midnight Sun.  SM does that a couple times with things, and I think she was setting it up for Midnight Sun.