If you had to pick between these three players on your fantasy team who would it be and why?

Question

Peyton Manning, Drew Brees or Tony Romo

Answer 1

Peyton Manning would be my pick. His consitant year in and year out has a low TD/INT ratio. Romo is good but he has his games where he doesnt do as good plus the cowboys havnt gone to far in the playoffs and the colts have more opportunity to get points. Drew Brees to be honest shouldnt even be in the picture. He needs to prove himself again like he did the year they went to the NFC championship game. But I will give him the benefit that he has a couple more weapon this year but until Reggie Bush steps his game up Brees or the saints wont really do anything.

Answer 2

Base don last year's stats Romo is the top. He has the best WR and better offense in terms of scoring. He threw more TDs then Peyton last season and is 100% healthy. Romo is huge in the regular season.

Peyton is a close second. He has more WRs to target but is coming off injury. He at one point, 3 yrs ago, was by and far the #1 QB overall and put up record numbers. Right now you'd have to give the nod to Romo given the Injury to him, Harrison's lost year last year and the deterioration OL.

Brees is a non factor compared to these 2. He's had 2 top fantasy years but nothing on the level of Romo and Peyton. Brees best years were his last in SD and his first in NO. If Duece is healthy and Reggie is at 100% Brees will have a good year but simply not as good as manning or Romo should have.

Answer 3

Peyton Manning. He is the most consistent (and just pure better) of those three quarterbacks.

Answer 4

Manning is in an established offense with great weapons. He proves year after year that he is the best QB in the league. But the players he has around him and the offensive scheme make him the best.

Romo is very good, but he plays by the seat of his pants. And when it's a big game and it's tight, he chokes. He also tries to force the ball to T.O. way too much and it costs the Cowboys big time.

Drew Brees is a question mark year to year. He has great ability and talent but his teammates are inconsistent and the running game is injury prone and ineffective.

All three have equal talent, but it takes much more than talent for a QB to be the best.

Answer 5

Peyton Manning is the most consistent QB in the league.  He has a proven track record and he is still at the top of his game.  When all is said and done, he may be the best QB of all time.

Answer 6

Definately Romo. He has lots of targets in Terrell Owens, Jason Whitten, and Patrick Crayton as well as a good run game. He will score lots of points tis year. Brees is however a close second. he also has many great weapons this year. Manning however, although a great QB, i wouldn't rank him higher than Brees or Romo in Fantasy. He doesn't score near as many fantasy points and you will be disappointed if you do decide to take him over the other two!

Answer 7

Alright, most of these people seemed to have missed the whole "Fantasy football" part of this question.  I agree with most of them that Peyton Manning is the better quarterback out of the 3...and actually, all 3 are top quarterbacks.  But fantasy-wise...I'd go with Brees.  Romo is a good quarterback, but the Cowboys are heavy on the run as well.  So Romo isn't gonna finish with 4000 yards passing.  Peyton Manning has been consistent...but who knows how bad Harrison is hurt and what kind of problems he'll have this year.  If it was guaranteed he was bouncing back to his old form, I'd go with Manning.  But it's not...so Brees would be my choice.  He has weapons at receivers...Shockey at tight end this year...plus his running back (Reggie Bush) is more of a receiver than a runner.  So that helps Brees' statistics.  Deuce is coming off of 2 knee injuries in 3 years...so less running going on for the Saints.  ***Plus a big key for choosing a fantasy quarterback is them being on a team that will be down.  If you're winning, you don't throw the ball as much.  Which team has the best chance of still being down in the 4th quarter out of the 3 teams?***

Answer 8

Probably Peyton. Brees is a close second. Romo, isn't anywhere near as good as either one of them. He stinks. He wants to be a celebrity, not a football player.

Answer 9

Manning.

consistancy.

Answer 10

I would go with Romo because Payton is still recovering. Last year Romo put up more points then Payton. The biggest "what if" is the health of marvin harrison? If marvin doesn't return to top form, then payton numbers will decline  

Answer 11

1) Peyton Manning : consitent fantasy performance for 5 years plus.  You know this guy will also be in the post season

2) Tony Romo : Good QB to have for the regular season.  However anyone who had this guy in the last 2 years was scrambling for another player in the post season.  

3) Drew Brees: Should do well with New Orleans this year.    

    

Answer 12

Peyton Manning cuz he is the better QB!

Answer 13

Tony Romo, because Manning is injured, and Romo is alot better than Drew Brees

Answer 14

i would have to say Tony because payton was hurt duing the offseason and brees isant to great

Answer 15

Peyton Manning, because he's Peyton Manning.

Joey C-Um, okay, Romo isn't even CLOSE to being as good as Brees.