If you had to trade one away?

Question

carson palmer and ryan grant and ?? 4 ap hasselback and brandon marshall

??=roy williams

or santana moss

or benard berrian

Answer 1

If you can wait a little bit and see if Marshall is going to be suspended, the announcement is supposed to come out this week.

If he is, it still might be worth it if it's a short suspension.

I would lean towards dropping Berrian at this point. He is still not in a great situation with QB play, is in a new system and you would have to cover Berrian, Marshall and AP during their bye, week 8.

Answer 2

Trade berrian and moss if you have to. Do whatever you can to get AP. If you only want to trade one trade berrian, he is in a new system with an unproven QB. Check out this blog on vikings and the errors made by jackson/berrian

http://ww3.startribune.com/vikingsblog/?...

Answer 3

Go with Moss or Berrian - preferrably Berrian.  Moss is in a new offensive system and should benefit from Jason Campbell's continued development as well as the addition of some solid rookie slot WR's.

Getting AP is HUUUUGGGEEE.  And Marshall is an upgrade on Berrian and Moss in his own right.

Answer 4

It would have to be Williams and I doubt that you could get that trade with him. Palmer and Hasselbeck are about the same (I'll give a slight edge to Carson). Peterson is a 1st or 2nd overall pick while Grant is a 2nd to 3rd round pick. Marshall is better than all the ?? recievers you put up there. If you have a top 5 ranked WR to offer then they might go for it, but I doubt it.

However, if you can get that trade for those players it would be a great trade and huge steal for you.

Answer 5

You could throw in all of those receivers and you'd still come out way ahead on the deal. I would be shocked if the other person gave up AP without getting more back.

Palmer for Hasselbeck is virtually a wash and Williams is the only one of the receivers comparable to Marshall. So basically it comes down to AP for Grant and that's not even close. Grant isn't even in camp yet and he's livid with the Packers contract offer so he might not be in anytime soon.

Good luck.

Answer 6

Yes.

Answer 7

Go with berrian he wont have as good of a year as the other two guys.

Answer 8

Personally, I wouldn't make this trade.  But, if you are, I would only be willing to give Berrian or Moss with Palmer and Grant.  There's a large upside to Marshall, but you are losing a strong #1 QB and at worst a #2 RB.  Just my opinion and hope it helps.  Good luck with the upcoming season!