If you were bell and you had to choose between Jacob Black and Edward Cullen who would you chose and why :D???

Question

I know my answer but I'm curious what others think! XDD

Answer 1

Edward Cullen; he's simply amazing.

He always has Bella's best interest at heart, and Bella never truly loved Jacob, not the way he though he loved her. There relationship was more on a brother-sister level to me, and Jacob says in Breaking Dawn that it was Renesmee keeping them so close back in Bella's dark time. [don't really get that bit] But Edward is just amazing, he is intelligent, handsome, caring, passionate, and protective. I could go on forever, his only flaw is maybe that he cares too much, which can be dangerous, but really even that's an admirable quality.

Answer 2

I'd wake up and realize that I was being stupid. I'd realize that I was being blind. I'd realize that I was being illogical. I'd realize that I was being a doormat and a slave. I'd realize that I was being abused. I'd realize that I wasn't THINKING.

I'd choose Jacob.

There's just SO MUCH he could offer. He could give you MORE than just love and forever. Sigh. I could just imagine what Bella and Jacob's adventures would have been....

It's so dumb that Bella chose Edward. The ending doesn't make sense to me.

None of this mess would have happened if she chose Jake instead...

Answer 3

Um.. as a guy..neither but If I were a guy and jacob and edward were feminine (just gender swap really) I'd def choose edward (edwardina) because he/she is so sweet and manly/womenly lol and has bella's thoughts at heart e.g. he cares for her more than himself. Hes gentle whilst harsh and definatley understanding. and in the end I think bella chose the right guy.... Jacob was soo..sweet yet he was rushing bella and he wasnt keeping her thoughts close to heart either e.g. he was ready to kill of bellas friends etc because they were vampires and he didnt think about her when he was like not answering her messages etcetera

Answer 4

I might grow up and realize that if I thought I loved two people, then I didn't know what REAL love is.  

Answer 5

Definitely Edward!!!!!

Well, I would personally hate to spend my life with a werewolf (ick!!)

And I I had to be with Edward we could be together forever. It would be much better then living with Jacob! I can't stand him!

Answer 6

Edward:

Smart

Totally hot

Jacob:

KNOWS HOW TO HAVE FUN

Can be sarcastic

Also hot :]

Doesn't need other people's approval

Laughs more often

tells more jokes

Warm

Warm hearted

I CAN GO ON FOREVER!!!

Sorry Edward fans.

I love Jacob.

You guys can have Edward. :]

Answer 7

Edward, fer sure

Well, after Breaking Dawn, I didn't like how Steph changed him so much

Losing his overprotective growling hotness ;]

And becoming a s*x addict D:

But he's such a gent, a romantic, gorgeous, and my fantasy man come true.

Minus the s*x addiction change of life

(roll of the eyes)

Answer 8

Edward! Definitely. He's gorgeous, strong, and protective over Bella. Jacob's like that too, but Edward is more mature and I just love his character more. I wish he was real. Also, whenever they touch or kiss, Bella's heart races and she probably feels like they're the only two people in the world. He can provide true love more than Jacob can. Edward is just an amazing guy.

Answer 9

oh def edward and after this last book when we heard what jacob sees through his own eyes he honestly went down a lot in my opinion im interested in seeing when the new book comes out through edwards perspective but though jacob is a great guy and a good friend how can you begin to look at someone like him when edward is in the room. He is honestly pure perfection and shaggy dog vs super hero unbeatable.

ha plus at this point you should know... jacobs a little preoccupied with other ladies at the moment so im not worried